:: Introduction to Modal Propositional Logic
:: by Alicia de la Cruz
::
:: Received September 30, 1991
:: Copyright (c) 1991-2011 Association of Mizar Users

begin

Lm1: for m being Element of NAT holds {} is_a_proper_prefix_of <*m*>

proof end;

definition

let Z be Tree;
func Root Z -> Element of Z equals :: MODAL_1:def 1
{} ;
coherence
{} is Element of Z by TREES_1:47;

end;

:: deftheorem defines Root MODAL_1:def 1 :
for Z being Tree holds Root Z = {} ;

definition

let D be non empty set ;
let T be DecoratedTree of D;
func Root T -> Element of D equals :: MODAL_1:def 2
T . (Root (dom T));
coherence
T . (Root (dom T)) is Element of D ;

end;

:: deftheorem defines Root MODAL_1:def 2 :
for D being non empty set
for T being DecoratedTree of D holds Root T = T . (Root (dom T));

theorem :: MODAL_1:1

canceled;

theorem :: MODAL_1:2

canceled;

theorem Th3: :: MODAL_1:3

for n, m being Element of NAT
for s being FinSequence of NAT st n <> m holds
not <*n*>,<*m*> ^ s are_c=-comparable

proof end;

theorem :: MODAL_1:4

for s being FinSequence of NAT st s <> {} holds
ex w being FinSequence of NAT ex n being Element of NAT st s = <*n*> ^ w by FINSEQ_2:150;

theorem Th5: :: MODAL_1:5

for n, m being Element of NAT
for s being FinSequence of NAT st n <> m holds
not <*n*> is_a_proper_prefix_of <*m*> ^ s

proof end;

theorem :: MODAL_1:6

for n, m being Element of NAT
for s being FinSequence of NAT st n <> m holds
not <*n*> is_a_prefix_of <*m*> ^ s by TREES_1:87;

theorem :: MODAL_1:7

for n, m being Element of NAT holds not <*n*> is_a_proper_prefix_of <*m*> by TREES_1:89;

theorem :: MODAL_1:8

canceled;

theorem :: MODAL_1:9

elementary_tree 1 = {{},<*0*>} by TREES_1:88;

theorem :: MODAL_1:10

elementary_tree 2 = {{},<*0*>,<*1*>} by TREES_1:90;

theorem Th11: :: MODAL_1:11

for Z being Tree
for n, m being Element of NAT st n <= m & <*m*> in Z holds
<*n*> in Z

proof end;

theorem :: MODAL_1:12

for w, t, s being FinSequence of NAT st w ^ t is_a_proper_prefix_of w ^ s holds
t is_a_proper_prefix_of s by TREES_1:86;

theorem Th13: :: MODAL_1:13

for t1 being DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] holds t1 in PFuncs ((NAT *),[:NAT,NAT:])

proof end;

theorem :: MODAL_1:14

canceled;

theorem Th15: :: MODAL_1:15

for Z, Z1, Z2 being Tree
for z being Element of Z st Z with-replacement (z,Z1) = Z with-replacement (z,Z2) holds
Z1 = Z2

proof end;

theorem Th16: :: MODAL_1:16

for D being non empty set
for Z, Z1, Z2 being DecoratedTree of D
for z being Element of dom Z st Z with-replacement (z,Z1) = Z with-replacement (z,Z2) holds
Z1 = Z2

proof end;

theorem Th17: :: MODAL_1:17

for Z1, Z2 being Tree
for p being FinSequence of NAT st p in Z1 holds
for v being Element of Z1 with-replacement (p,Z2)
for w being Element of Z1 st v = w & w is_a_proper_prefix_of p holds
succ v = succ w

proof end;

theorem Th18: :: MODAL_1:18

for Z1, Z2 being Tree
for p being FinSequence of NAT st p in Z1 holds
for v being Element of Z1 with-replacement (p,Z2)
for w being Element of Z1 st v = w & not p,w are_c=-comparable holds
succ v = succ w

proof end;

theorem :: MODAL_1:19

for Z1, Z2 being Tree
for p being FinSequence of NAT st p in Z1 holds
for v being Element of Z1 with-replacement (p,Z2)
for w being Element of Z2 st v = p ^ w holds
succ v, succ w are_equipotent by TREES_2:39;

theorem Th20: :: MODAL_1:20

for Z1 being Tree
for p being FinSequence of NAT st p in Z1 holds
for v being Element of Z1
for w being Element of Z1 | p st v = p ^ w holds
succ v, succ w are_equipotent

proof end;

theorem :: MODAL_1:21

canceled;

theorem Th22: :: MODAL_1:22

for Z being finite Tree st branchdeg (Root Z) = 0 holds
( card Z = 1 & Z = {{}} )

proof end;

theorem Th23: :: MODAL_1:23

for Z being finite Tree st branchdeg (Root Z) = 1 holds
succ (Root Z) = {<*0*>}

proof end;

theorem Th24: :: MODAL_1:24

for Z being finite Tree st branchdeg (Root Z) = 2 holds
succ (Root Z) = {<*0*>,<*1*>}

proof end;

theorem Th25: :: MODAL_1:25

for Z being Tree
for o being Element of Z st o <> Root Z holds
( Z | o, { (o ^ s9) where s9 is Element of NAT * : o ^ s9 in Z } are_equipotent & not Root Z in { (o ^ w9) where w9 is Element of NAT * : o ^ w9 in Z } )

proof end;

theorem Th26: :: MODAL_1:26

for Z being finite Tree
for o being Element of Z st o <> Root Z holds
card (Z | o) < card Z

proof end;

theorem Th27: :: MODAL_1:27

for Z being finite Tree
for z being Element of Z st succ (Root Z) = {z} holds
Z = (elementary_tree 1) with-replacement (<*0*>,(Z | z))

proof end;

Lm2: for f being Function st dom f is finite holds
f is finite

proof end;

theorem Th28: :: MODAL_1:28

for D being non empty set
for Z being finite DecoratedTree of D
for z being Element of dom Z st succ (Root (dom Z)) = {z} holds
Z = ((elementary_tree 1) --> (Root Z)) with-replacement (<*0*>,(Z | z))

proof end;

theorem Th29: :: MODAL_1:29

for Z being Tree
for x1, x2 being Element of Z st x1 = <*0*> & x2 = <*1*> & succ (Root Z) = {x1,x2} holds
Z = ((elementary_tree 2) with-replacement (<*0*>,(Z | x1))) with-replacement (<*1*>,(Z | x2))

proof end;

theorem Th30: :: MODAL_1:30

for D being non empty set
for Z being DecoratedTree of D
for x1, x2 being Element of dom Z st x1 = <*0*> & x2 = <*1*> & succ (Root (dom Z)) = {x1,x2} holds
Z = (((elementary_tree 2) --> (Root Z)) with-replacement (<*0*>,(Z | x1))) with-replacement (<*1*>,(Z | x2))

proof end;

definition

func MP-variables -> set equals :: MODAL_1:def 3
[:{3},NAT:];
coherence
[:{3},NAT:] is set ;

end;

:: deftheorem defines MP-variables MODAL_1:def 3 :
MP-variables = [:{3},NAT:];

registration

cluster MP-variables -> non empty ;
coherence
not MP-variables is empty ;

end;

definition

mode MP-variable is Element of MP-variables ;

end;

definition

func MP-conectives -> set equals :: MODAL_1:def 4
[:{0,1,2},NAT:];
coherence
[:{0,1,2},NAT:] is set ;

end;

:: deftheorem defines MP-conectives MODAL_1:def 4 :
MP-conectives = [:{0,1,2},NAT:];

registration

cluster MP-conectives -> non empty ;
coherence
not MP-conectives is empty ;

end;

definition

mode MP-conective is Element of MP-conectives ;

end;

theorem Th31: :: MODAL_1:31

MP-conectives misses MP-variables

proof end;

definition

let T be finite Tree;
let v be Element of T;
:: original: branchdeg
redefine func branchdeg v -> Element of NAT ;
coherence
branchdeg v is Element of NAT

proof end;

end;

definition

let D be non empty set ;
mode DOMAIN_DecoratedTree of D -> non empty set means :Def5: :: MODAL_1:def 5
for x being set st x in it holds
x is DecoratedTree of D;
existence
ex b₁ being non empty set st
for x being set st x in b₁ holds
x is DecoratedTree of D

proof end;

end;

:: deftheorem Def5 defines DOMAIN_DecoratedTree MODAL_1:def 5 :
for D, b₂ being non empty set holds
( b₂ is DOMAIN_DecoratedTree of D iff for x being set st x in b₂ holds
x is DecoratedTree of D );

registration

let D0 be non empty set ;
let D be DOMAIN_DecoratedTree of D0;
cluster -> Relation-like Function-like Element of D;
coherence
for b₁ being Element of D holds
( b₁ is Function-like & b₁ is Relation-like ) by Def5;

end;

registration

let D0 be non empty set ;
let D be DOMAIN_DecoratedTree of D0;
cluster -> D0 -valued DecoratedTree-like Element of D;
coherence
for b₁ being Element of D holds
( b₁ is D0 -valued & b₁ is DecoratedTree-like ) by Def5;

end;

definition

func MP-WFF -> DOMAIN_DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] means :Def6: :: MODAL_1:def 6
( ( for x being DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] st x in it holds
x is finite ) & ( for x being finite DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] holds
( x in it iff for v being Element of dom x holds
( branchdeg v <= 2 & ( not branchdeg v = 0 or x . v = [0,0] or ex k being Element of NAT st x . v = [3,k] ) & ( not branchdeg v = 1 or x . v = [1,0] or x . v = [1,1] ) & ( branchdeg v = 2 implies x . v = [2,0] ) ) ) ) );
existence
ex b₁ being DOMAIN_DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] st
( ( for x being DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] st x in b₁ holds
x is finite ) & ( for x being finite DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] holds
( x in b₁ iff for v being Element of dom x holds
( branchdeg v <= 2 & ( not branchdeg v = 0 or x . v = [0,0] or ex k being Element of NAT st x . v = [3,k] ) & ( not branchdeg v = 1 or x . v = [1,0] or x . v = [1,1] ) & ( branchdeg v = 2 implies x . v = [2,0] ) ) ) ) )

proof end;

uniqueness
for b₁, b₂ being DOMAIN_DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] st ( for x being DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] st x in b₁ holds
x is finite ) & ( for x being finite DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] holds
( x in b₁ iff for v being Element of dom x holds
( branchdeg v <= 2 & ( not branchdeg v = 0 or x . v = [0,0] or ex k being Element of NAT st x . v = [3,k] ) & ( not branchdeg v = 1 or x . v = [1,0] or x . v = [1,1] ) & ( branchdeg v = 2 implies x . v = [2,0] ) ) ) ) & ( for x being DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] st x in b₂ holds
x is finite ) & ( for x being finite DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] holds
( x in b₂ iff for v being Element of dom x holds
( branchdeg v <= 2 & ( not branchdeg v = 0 or x . v = [0,0] or ex k being Element of NAT st x . v = [3,k] ) & ( not branchdeg v = 1 or x . v = [1,0] or x . v = [1,1] ) & ( branchdeg v = 2 implies x . v = [2,0] ) ) ) ) holds
b₁ = b₂

proof end;

end;

:: deftheorem Def6 defines MP-WFF MODAL_1:def 6 :
for b₁ being DOMAIN_DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] holds
( b₁ = MP-WFF iff ( ( for x being DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] st x in b₁ holds
x is finite ) & ( for x being finite DecoratedTree of [:NAT,NAT:] holds
( x in b₁ iff for v being Element of dom x holds
( branchdeg v <= 2 & ( not branchdeg v = 0 or x . v = [0,0] or ex k being Element of NAT st x . v = [3,k] ) & ( not branchdeg v = 1 or x . v = [1,0] or x . v = [1,1] ) & ( branchdeg v = 2 implies x . v = [2,0] ) ) ) ) ) );

definition

mode MP-wff is Element of MP-WFF ;

end;

registration

cluster -> finite Element of MP-WFF ;
coherence
for b₁ being MP-wff holds b₁ is finite by Def6;

end;

definition

let A be MP-wff;
let a be Element of dom A;
:: original: |
redefine func A | a -> MP-wff;
coherence
A | a is MP-wff

proof end;

end;

definition

let a be Element of MP-conectives ;
func the_arity_of a -> Element of NAT equals :: MODAL_1:def 7
a `1 ;
coherence
a `1 is Element of NAT

proof end;

end;

:: deftheorem defines the_arity_of MODAL_1:def 7 :
for a being Element of MP-conectives holds the_arity_of a = a `1 ;

definition

let D be non empty set ;
let T, T1 be DecoratedTree of D;
let p be FinSequence of NAT ;
assume A1: p in dom T ;
func @ (T,p,T1) -> DecoratedTree of D equals :Def8: :: MODAL_1:def 8
T with-replacement (p,T1);
coherence
T with-replacement (p,T1) is DecoratedTree of D

proof end;

end;

:: deftheorem Def8 defines @ MODAL_1:def 8 :
for D being non empty set
for T, T1 being DecoratedTree of D
for p being FinSequence of NAT st p in dom T holds
@ (T,p,T1) = T with-replacement (p,T1);

theorem Th32: :: MODAL_1:32

for A being MP-wff holds ((elementary_tree 1) --> [1,0]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A) is MP-wff

proof end;

theorem Th33: :: MODAL_1:33

for A being MP-wff holds ((elementary_tree 1) --> [1,1]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A) is MP-wff

proof end;

theorem Th34: :: MODAL_1:34

for A, B being MP-wff holds (((elementary_tree 2) --> [2,0]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A)) with-replacement (<*1*>,B) is MP-wff

proof end;

definition

let A be MP-wff;
func 'not' A -> MP-wff equals :: MODAL_1:def 9
((elementary_tree 1) --> [1,0]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A);
coherence
((elementary_tree 1) --> [1,0]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A) is MP-wff by Th32;
func (#) A -> MP-wff equals :: MODAL_1:def 10
((elementary_tree 1) --> [1,1]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A);
coherence
((elementary_tree 1) --> [1,1]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A) is MP-wff by Th33;
let B be MP-wff;
func A '&' B -> MP-wff equals :: MODAL_1:def 11
(((elementary_tree 2) --> [2,0]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A)) with-replacement (<*1*>,B);
coherence
(((elementary_tree 2) --> [2,0]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A)) with-replacement (<*1*>,B) is MP-wff by Th34;

end;

:: deftheorem defines 'not' MODAL_1:def 9 :
for A being MP-wff holds 'not' A = ((elementary_tree 1) --> [1,0]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A);

:: deftheorem defines (#) MODAL_1:def 10 :
for A being MP-wff holds (#) A = ((elementary_tree 1) --> [1,1]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A);

:: deftheorem defines '&' MODAL_1:def 11 :
for A, B being MP-wff holds A '&' B = (((elementary_tree 2) --> [2,0]) with-replacement (<*0*>,A)) with-replacement (<*1*>,B);

definition

let A be MP-wff;
func ? A -> MP-wff equals :: MODAL_1:def 12
'not' ((#) ('not' A));
correctness
coherence
'not' ((#) ('not' A)) is MP-wff;
;
let B be MP-wff;
func A 'or' B -> MP-wff equals :: MODAL_1:def 13
'not' (('not' A) '&' ('not' B));
correctness
coherence
'not' (('not' A) '&' ('not' B)) is MP-wff;
;
func A => B -> MP-wff equals :: MODAL_1:def 14
'not' (A '&' ('not' B));
correctness
coherence
'not' (A '&' ('not' B)) is MP-wff;
;

end;

:: deftheorem defines ? MODAL_1:def 12 :
for A being MP-wff holds ? A = 'not' ((#) ('not' A));

:: deftheorem defines 'or' MODAL_1:def 13 :
for A, B being MP-wff holds A 'or' B = 'not' (('not' A) '&' ('not' B));

:: deftheorem defines => MODAL_1:def 14 :
for A, B being MP-wff holds A => B = 'not' (A '&' ('not' B));

theorem Th35: :: MODAL_1:35

for n being Element of NAT holds (elementary_tree 0) --> [3,n] is MP-wff

proof end;

theorem Th36: :: MODAL_1:36

(elementary_tree 0) --> [0,0] is MP-wff

proof end;

definition

let p be MP-variable;
func @ p -> MP-wff equals :: MODAL_1:def 15
(elementary_tree 0) --> p;
coherence
(elementary_tree 0) --> p is MP-wff

proof end;

end;

:: deftheorem defines @ MODAL_1:def 15 :
for p being MP-variable holds @ p = (elementary_tree 0) --> p;

theorem Th37: :: MODAL_1:37

for p, q being MP-variable st @ p = @ q holds
p = q

proof end;

Lm3: for n, m being Element of NAT holds <*0*> in dom ((elementary_tree 1) --> [n,m])

proof end;

theorem Th38: :: MODAL_1:38

for A, B being MP-wff st 'not' A = 'not' B holds
A = B

proof end;

theorem Th39: :: MODAL_1:39

for A, B being MP-wff st (#) A = (#) B holds
A = B

proof end;

theorem Th40: :: MODAL_1:40

for A, B, A1, B1 being MP-wff st A '&' B = A1 '&' B1 holds
( A = A1 & B = B1 )

proof end;

definition

func VERUM -> MP-wff equals :: MODAL_1:def 16
(elementary_tree 0) --> [0,0];
coherence
(elementary_tree 0) --> [0,0] is MP-wff by Th36;

end;

:: deftheorem defines VERUM MODAL_1:def 16 :
VERUM = (elementary_tree 0) --> [0,0];

theorem :: MODAL_1:41

canceled;

theorem Th42: :: MODAL_1:42

for A being MP-wff holds
( not card (dom A) = 1 or A = VERUM or ex p being MP-variable st A = @ p )

proof end;

theorem Th43: :: MODAL_1:43

for A being MP-wff holds
( not card (dom A) >= 2 or ex B being MP-wff st
( A = 'not' B or A = (#) B ) or ex B, C being MP-wff st A = B '&' C )

proof end;

theorem Th44: :: MODAL_1:44

for A being MP-wff holds card (dom A) < card (dom ('not' A))

proof end;

theorem Th45: :: MODAL_1:45

for A being MP-wff holds card (dom A) < card (dom ((#) A))

proof end;

theorem Th46: :: MODAL_1:46

for A, B being MP-wff holds
( card (dom A) < card (dom (A '&' B)) & card (dom B) < card (dom (A '&' B)) )

proof end;

definition

let IT be MP-wff;
attr IT is atomic means :Def17: :: MODAL_1:def 17
ex p being MP-variable st IT = @ p;
attr IT is negative means :Def18: :: MODAL_1:def 18
ex A being MP-wff st IT = 'not' A;
attr IT is necessitive means :Def19: :: MODAL_1:def 19
ex A being MP-wff st IT = (#) A;
attr IT is conjunctive means :Def20: :: MODAL_1:def 20
ex A, B being MP-wff st IT = A '&' B;

end;

:: deftheorem Def17 defines atomic MODAL_1:def 17 :
for IT being MP-wff holds
( IT is atomic iff ex p being MP-variable st IT = @ p );

:: deftheorem Def18 defines negative MODAL_1:def 18 :
for IT being MP-wff holds
( IT is negative iff ex A being MP-wff st IT = 'not' A );

:: deftheorem Def19 defines necessitive MODAL_1:def 19 :
for IT being MP-wff holds
( IT is necessitive iff ex A being MP-wff st IT = (#) A );

:: deftheorem Def20 defines conjunctive MODAL_1:def 20 :
for IT being MP-wff holds
( IT is conjunctive iff ex A, B being MP-wff st IT = A '&' B );

registration

cluster Relation-like [:NAT,NAT:] -valued Function-like finite DecoratedTree-like atomic Element of MP-WFF ;
existence
ex b₁ being MP-wff st b₁ is atomic

proof end;

cluster Relation-like [:NAT,NAT:] -valued Function-like finite DecoratedTree-like negative Element of MP-WFF ;
existence
ex b₁ being MP-wff st b₁ is negative

proof end;

cluster Relation-like [:NAT,NAT:] -valued Function-like finite DecoratedTree-like necessitive Element of MP-WFF ;
existence
ex b₁ being MP-wff st b₁ is necessitive

proof end;

cluster Relation-like [:NAT,NAT:] -valued Function-like finite DecoratedTree-like conjunctive Element of MP-WFF ;
existence
ex b₁ being MP-wff st b₁ is conjunctive

proof end;

end;

scheme :: MODAL_1:sch 1
MPInd{ P₁[ Element of MP-WFF ] } :

for A being Element of MP-WFF holds P₁[A]

provided

A1: P₁[ VERUM ] and
A2: for p being MP-variable holds P₁[ @ p] and
A3: for A being Element of MP-WFF st P₁[A] holds
P₁[ 'not' A] and
A4: for A being Element of MP-WFF st P₁[A] holds
P₁[ (#) A] and
A5: for A, B being Element of MP-WFF st P₁[A] & P₁[B] holds
P₁[A '&' B]

proof end;

theorem :: MODAL_1:47

for A being Element of MP-WFF holds
( A = VERUM or A is atomic MP-wff or A is negative MP-wff or A is necessitive MP-wff or A is conjunctive MP-wff )

proof end;

theorem Th48: :: MODAL_1:48

for A being MP-wff holds
( A = VERUM or ex p being MP-variable st A = @ p or ex B being MP-wff st A = 'not' B or ex B being MP-wff st A = (#) B or ex B, C being MP-wff st A = B '&' C )

proof end;

theorem Th49: :: MODAL_1:49

for p being MP-variable
for A, B being MP-wff holds
( @ p <> 'not' A & @ p <> (#) A & @ p <> A '&' B )

proof end;

theorem Th50: :: MODAL_1:50

for A, B, C being MP-wff holds
( 'not' A <> (#) B & 'not' A <> B '&' C )

proof end;

theorem Th51: :: MODAL_1:51

for A, B, C being MP-wff holds (#) A <> B '&' C

proof end;

Lm4: for A, B being MP-wff holds
( VERUM <> 'not' A & VERUM <> (#) A & VERUM <> A '&' B )

proof end;

Lm5: [0,0] is MP-conective

proof end;

Lm6: for p being MP-variable holds VERUM <> @ p

proof end;

theorem :: MODAL_1:52

for p being MP-variable
for A, B being MP-wff holds
( VERUM <> @ p & VERUM <> 'not' A & VERUM <> (#) A & VERUM <> A '&' B ) by Lm4, Lm6;

scheme :: MODAL_1:sch 2
MPFuncEx{ F₁() -> non empty set , F₂() -> Element of F₁(), F₃( Element of MP-variables ) -> Element of F₁(), F₄( Element of F₁()) -> Element of F₁(), F₅( Element of F₁()) -> Element of F₁(), F₆( Element of F₁(), Element of F₁()) -> Element of F₁() } :

ex f being Function of MP-WFF,F₁() st
( f . VERUM = F₂() & ( for p being MP-variable holds f . (@ p) = F₃(p) ) & ( for A being Element of MP-WFF holds f . ('not' A) = F₄((f . A)) ) & ( for A being Element of MP-WFF holds f . ((#) A) = F₅((f . A)) ) & ( for A, B being Element of MP-WFF holds f . (A '&' B) = F₆((f . A),(f . B)) ) )

proof end;