let F be Field; for V being finite-dimensional VectSp of F
for W1, W2, P, Q being Subspace of V
for k being Nat st (dim W1) + 1 = k & dim W2 = k + 1 & P in pencil (W1,W2,k) & Q in pencil (W1,W2,k) & P <> Q holds
( P /\ Q = (Omega). W1 & P + Q = (Omega). W2 )
let V be finite-dimensional VectSp of F; for W1, W2, P, Q being Subspace of V
for k being Nat st (dim W1) + 1 = k & dim W2 = k + 1 & P in pencil (W1,W2,k) & Q in pencil (W1,W2,k) & P <> Q holds
( P /\ Q = (Omega). W1 & P + Q = (Omega). W2 )
let W1, W2, P0, Q0 be Subspace of V; for k being Nat st (dim W1) + 1 = k & dim W2 = k + 1 & P0 in pencil (W1,W2,k) & Q0 in pencil (W1,W2,k) & P0 <> Q0 holds
( P0 /\ Q0 = (Omega). W1 & P0 + Q0 = (Omega). W2 )
let k be Nat; ( (dim W1) + 1 = k & dim W2 = k + 1 & P0 in pencil (W1,W2,k) & Q0 in pencil (W1,W2,k) & P0 <> Q0 implies ( P0 /\ Q0 = (Omega). W1 & P0 + Q0 = (Omega). W2 ) )
assume that
A1:
(dim W1) + 1 = k
and
A2:
dim W2 = k + 1
and
A3:
P0 in pencil (W1,W2,k)
and
A4:
Q0 in pencil (W1,W2,k)
and
A5:
P0 <> Q0
; ( P0 /\ Q0 = (Omega). W1 & P0 + Q0 = (Omega). W2 )
consider Q being strict Subspace of V such that
A6:
Q = Q0
and
A7:
dim Q = k
by A4, VECTSP_9:def 2;
A8:
W1 is Subspace of Q
by A4, A6, Th8;
consider P being strict Subspace of V such that
A9:
P = P0
and
A10:
dim P = k
by A3, VECTSP_9:def 2;
W1 is Subspace of P
by A3, A9, Th8;
then A11:
W1 is Subspace of P /\ Q
by A8, VECTSP_5:19;
P /\ Q is Subspace of P
by VECTSP_5:15;
then A12:
dim (P /\ Q) <= k
by A10, VECTSP_9:25;
per cases
( dim W1 = dim (P /\ Q) or dim (P /\ Q) = k )
by A1, A12, A11, NAT_1:9, VECTSP_9:25;
suppose A13:
dim W1 = dim (P /\ Q)
;
( P0 /\ Q0 = (Omega). W1 & P0 + Q0 = (Omega). W2 )then
(Omega). W1 = (Omega). (P /\ Q)
by A11, VECTSP_9:28;
hence
P0 /\ Q0 = (Omega). W1
by A9, A6;
P0 + Q0 = (Omega). W2
(
P is
Subspace of
W2 &
Q is
Subspace of
W2 )
by A3, A4, A9, A6, Th8;
then A14:
P + Q is
Subspace of
W2
by VECTSP_5:34;
((dim (P + Q)) + (dim W1)) - (dim W1) = ((dim P) + (dim Q)) - (dim W1)
by A13, VECTSP_9:32;
then
(Omega). W2 = (Omega). (P + Q)
by A1, A2, A10, A7, A14, VECTSP_9:28;
hence
P0 + Q0 = (Omega). W2
by A9, A6;
verum end; end;