let F be Field; for a, b, c being Element of (MPS F) st a,b '||' a,c holds
b,a '||' b,c
let a, b, c be Element of (MPS F); ( a,b '||' a,c implies b,a '||' b,c )
assume
a,b '||' a,c
; b,a '||' b,c
then consider e, f, g, h being Element of [: the carrier of F, the carrier of F, the carrier of F:] such that
A1:
[[e,f],[g,h]] = [[a,b],[a,c]]
and
A2:
( (((e `1_3) - (f `1_3)) * ((g `2_3) - (h `2_3))) - (((g `1_3) - (h `1_3)) * ((e `2_3) - (f `2_3))) = 0. F & (((e `1_3) - (f `1_3)) * ((g `3_3) - (h `3_3))) - (((g `1_3) - (h `1_3)) * ((e `3_3) - (f `3_3))) = 0. F )
and
A3:
(((e `2_3) - (f `2_3)) * ((g `3_3) - (h `3_3))) - (((g `2_3) - (h `2_3)) * ((e `3_3) - (f `3_3))) = 0. F
by Th12;
A4:
e = a
by A1, MCART_1:93;
A5:
g = a
by A1, MCART_1:93;
then A6:
(((f `2_3) - (e `2_3)) * ((f `3_3) - (h `3_3))) - (((f `2_3) - (h `2_3)) * ((f `3_3) - (e `3_3))) = 0. F
by A3, A4, Lm13;
f = b
by A1, MCART_1:93;
then A7:
[[f,e],[f,h]] = [[b,a],[b,c]]
by A1, A4, MCART_1:93;
( (((f `1_3) - (e `1_3)) * ((f `2_3) - (h `2_3))) - (((f `1_3) - (h `1_3)) * ((f `2_3) - (e `2_3))) = 0. F & (((f `1_3) - (e `1_3)) * ((f `3_3) - (h `3_3))) - (((f `1_3) - (h `1_3)) * ((f `3_3) - (e `3_3))) = 0. F )
by A2, A4, A5, Lm13;
hence
b,a '||' b,c
by A7, A6, Th12; verum