let PCPP be CollProjectiveSpace; for c1, c2, c3, c4, c5, c9 being Element of PCPP st c4 <> c1 & c4 <> c3 & not c1,c2,c5 are_collinear & c1,c2,c3 are_collinear & c1,c2,c4 are_collinear & c4,c5,c9 are_collinear holds
c9 <> c3
let c1, c2, c3, c4, c5, c9 be Element of PCPP; ( c4 <> c1 & c4 <> c3 & not c1,c2,c5 are_collinear & c1,c2,c3 are_collinear & c1,c2,c4 are_collinear & c4,c5,c9 are_collinear implies c9 <> c3 )
assume that
A1:
not c4 = c1
and
A2:
not c4 = c3
and
A3:
not c1,c2,c5 are_collinear
and
A4:
c1,c2,c3 are_collinear
and
A5:
c1,c2,c4 are_collinear
and
A6:
c4,c5,c9 are_collinear
and
A7:
c9 = c3
; contradiction
now ( ( not c2 = c1 or c1,c2,c5 are_collinear ) & c1,c4,c2 are_collinear & ( not c4,c3,c1 are_collinear or c1,c4,c5 are_collinear ) & ( for v102, v103, v100, v104 being Element of PCPP holds
( v100 = v104 or not v104,v100,v102 are_collinear or not v104,v100,v103 are_collinear or v102,v103,v104 are_collinear ) ) )thus
( not
c2 = c1 or
c1,
c2,
c5 are_collinear )
by COLLSP:2;
( c1,c4,c2 are_collinear & ( not c4,c3,c1 are_collinear or c1,c4,c5 are_collinear ) & ( for v102, v103, v100, v104 being Element of PCPP holds
( v100 = v104 or not v104,v100,v102 are_collinear or not v104,v100,v103 are_collinear or v102,v103,v104 are_collinear ) ) )thus
c1,
c4,
c2 are_collinear
by A5, COLLSP:4;
( ( not c4,c3,c1 are_collinear or c1,c4,c5 are_collinear ) & ( for v102, v103, v100, v104 being Element of PCPP holds
( v100 = v104 or not v104,v100,v102 are_collinear or not v104,v100,v103 are_collinear or v102,v103,v104 are_collinear ) ) )now ( ( for v102, v104, v100, v103 being Element of PCPP holds
( v100 = v103 or not v103,v100,v102 are_collinear or not v103,v100,v104 are_collinear or v102,v103,v104 are_collinear ) ) & ( not c4,c5,c3 are_collinear or c4,c3,c5 are_collinear ) )thus
for
v102,
v104,
v100,
v103 being
Element of
PCPP holds
(
v100 = v103 or not
v103,
v100,
v102 are_collinear or not
v103,
v100,
v104 are_collinear or
v102,
v103,
v104 are_collinear )
( not c4,c5,c3 are_collinear or c4,c3,c5 are_collinear )proof
let v102,
v104,
v100,
v103 be
Element of
PCPP;
( v100 = v103 or not v103,v100,v102 are_collinear or not v103,v100,v104 are_collinear or v102,v103,v104 are_collinear )
v103,
v100,
v103 are_collinear
by COLLSP:5;
hence
(
v100 = v103 or not
v103,
v100,
v102 are_collinear or not
v103,
v100,
v104 are_collinear or
v102,
v103,
v104 are_collinear )
by COLLSP:3;
verum
end; thus
( not
c4,
c5,
c3 are_collinear or
c4,
c3,
c5 are_collinear )
by COLLSP:4;
verum end; hence
( not
c4,
c3,
c1 are_collinear or
c1,
c4,
c5 are_collinear )
by A6, A7, A2;
for v102, v103, v100, v104 being Element of PCPP holds
( v100 = v104 or not v104,v100,v102 are_collinear or not v104,v100,v103 are_collinear or v102,v103,v104 are_collinear )thus
for
v102,
v103,
v100,
v104 being
Element of
PCPP holds
(
v100 = v104 or not
v104,
v100,
v102 are_collinear or not
v104,
v100,
v103 are_collinear or
v102,
v103,
v104 are_collinear )
verumproof
let v102,
v103,
v100,
v104 be
Element of
PCPP;
( v100 = v104 or not v104,v100,v102 are_collinear or not v104,v100,v103 are_collinear or v102,v103,v104 are_collinear )
v104,
v100,
v104 are_collinear
by COLLSP:5;
hence
(
v100 = v104 or not
v104,
v100,
v102 are_collinear or not
v104,
v100,
v103 are_collinear or
v102,
v103,
v104 are_collinear )
by COLLSP:3;
verum
end; end;
hence
contradiction
by A1, A3, A4, HESSENBE:2, A5; verum