thus ( ( for x, y, z being positive Nat holds (x / y) + (y / z) <> z / x ) implies for u, v, w being positive Nat holds (u |^ 3) + (v |^ 3) <> w |^ 3 ) :: thesis: ( ( for u, v, w being positive Nat holds (u |^ 3) + (v |^ 3) <> w |^ 3 ) implies for x, y, z being positive Nat holds (x / y) + (y / z) <> z / x )
proof
assume A1: for x, y, z being positive Nat holds (x / y) + (y / z) <> z / x ; :: thesis: for u, v, w being positive Nat holds (u |^ 3) + (v |^ 3) <> w |^ 3
given u, v, w being positive Nat such that A2: (u |^ 3) + (v |^ 3) = w |^ 3 ; :: thesis: contradiction
set x = (u ^2) * v;
set y = (v ^2) * w;
set z = (w ^2) * u;
A3: ( u |^ 3 = (u * u) * u & v |^ 3 = (v * v) * v & w |^ 3 = (w * w) * w ) by POLYEQ_5:2;
(((u ^2) * v) / ((v ^2) * w)) + (((v ^2) * w) / ((w ^2) * u)) = (((u ^2) * v) / ((v * w) * v)) + (((v ^2) * w) / ((w * u) * w))
.= ((u ^2) / (v * w)) + (((v ^2) * w) / ((w * u) * w)) by XCMPLX_1:91
.= ((u ^2) / (v * w)) + ((v ^2) / (w * u)) by XCMPLX_1:91
.= (((u ^2) * u) / ((v * w) * u)) + ((v ^2) / (w * u)) by XCMPLX_1:91
.= (((u ^2) * u) / ((v * w) * u)) + (((v ^2) * v) / ((w * u) * v)) by XCMPLX_1:91
.= (w |^ 3) / ((w * u) * v) by A2, A3
.= ((w ^2) * w) / ((u * v) * w) by POLYEQ_5:2
.= (w ^2) / (u * v) by XCMPLX_1:91
.= ((w ^2) * u) / ((u * v) * u) by XCMPLX_1:91
.= ((w ^2) * u) / ((u ^2) * v) ;
hence contradiction by A1; :: thesis: verum
end;
assume A4: for u, v, w being positive Nat holds (u |^ 3) + (v |^ 3) <> w |^ 3 ; :: thesis: for x, y, z being positive Nat holds (x / y) + (y / z) <> z / x
given x, y, z being positive Nat such that A5: (x / y) + (y / z) = z / x ; :: thesis: contradiction
set a = (x ^2) * z;
set b = (y ^2) * x;
(x / y) + (y / z) = ((x * z) + (y ^2)) / (y * z) by XCMPLX_1:116;
then z * (y * z) = x * ((x * z) + (y ^2)) by A5, XCMPLX_1:95;
then A6: (((x ^2) * z) * ((y ^2) * x)) * (((x ^2) * z) + ((y ^2) * x)) = (((x ^2) * z) * ((y ^2) * x)) * ((z ^2) * y)
.= (((x * y) * z) * ((x * y) * z)) * ((x * y) * z) ;
set d = ((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x);
consider a1, b1 being Nat such that
A7: ( (x ^2) * z = (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * a1 & (y ^2) * x = (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * b1 ) and
A8: a1,b1 are_coprime by NUMBER03:18;
reconsider a1 = a1, b1 = b1 as positive Nat by A7;
A9: ( (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) |^ 3 = ((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x))) * (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) & ((x * y) * z) |^ 3 = (((x * y) * z) * ((x * y) * z)) * ((x * y) * z) ) by POLYEQ_5:2;
A10: ((a1 * b1) * (a1 + b1)) * (((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x))) * (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x))) = (((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * a1) * ((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * b1)) * ((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * (a1 + b1))
.= (((x * y) * z) * ((x * y) * z)) * ((x * y) * z) by A6, A7 ;
then ((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x))) * (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) divides (((x * y) * z) * ((x * y) * z)) * ((x * y) * z) ;
then consider t being Nat such that
A11: (x * y) * z = (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * t by A9, WSIERP_1:26, NAT_D:def 3;
A12: ((a1 * b1) * (a1 + b1)) * (((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x))) * (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x))) = (((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * t) * ((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * t)) * ((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * t) by A10, A11
.= ((t * t) * t) * (((((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x)) * (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x))) * (((x ^2) * z) gcd ((y ^2) * x))) ;
A13: t |^ 3 = (t * t) * t by POLYEQ_5:2;
A14: 3 = (2 * 1) + 1 ;
A15: ( (1 * a1) + b1,a1 are_coprime & (1 * b1) + a1,b1 are_coprime ) by A8, NUMBER04:64;
then a1,b1,a1 + b1 are_mutually_coprime by A8;
then consider u being Nat such that
A16: u |^ 3 = a1 by A12, A13, Th86, XCMPLX_1:5;
A17: u is positive by A14, A16;
A18: (a1 * (a1 + b1)) * b1 = (a1 * b1) * (a1 + b1) ;
a1 + b1,a1,b1 are_mutually_coprime by A8, A15;
then consider v being Nat such that
A19: v |^ 3 = a1 + b1 by A12, A13, A18, Th86, XCMPLX_1:5;
A20: v is positive by A14, A19;
b1,a1,a1 + b1 are_mutually_coprime by A8, A15;
then consider w being Nat such that
A21: w |^ 3 = b1 by A12, A13, Th86, XCMPLX_1:5;
w is positive by A14, A21;
hence contradiction by A4, A16, A17, A19, A20, A21; :: thesis: verum