let S be non empty satisfying_Real MusicStruct ; ( S is satisfying_euclidean implies S is satisfying_commutativity )
assume A1:
S is satisfying_euclidean
; S is satisfying_commutativity
now for f1, f2, f3, f4 being Element of S st the Ratio of S . (f2,f1) = the Ratio of S . (f4,f3) holds
the Ratio of S . (f1,f2) = the Ratio of S . (f3,f4)let f1,
f2,
f3,
f4 be
Element of
S;
( the Ratio of S . (f2,f1) = the Ratio of S . (f4,f3) implies the Ratio of S . (f1,f2) = the Ratio of S . (f3,f4) )assume
the
Ratio of
S . (
f2,
f1)
= the
Ratio of
S . (
f4,
f3)
;
the Ratio of S . (f1,f2) = the Ratio of S . (f3,f4)then A2:
(@ f1) / (@ f2) =
the
Ratio of
S . (
f4,
f3)
by A1
.=
(@ f3) / (@ f4)
by A1
;
thus the
Ratio of
S . (
f1,
f2) =
(@ f2) / (@ f1)
by A1
.=
1
/ ((@ f1) / (@ f2))
by XCMPLX_1:57
.=
(@ f4) / (@ f3)
by A2, XCMPLX_1:57
.=
the
Ratio of
S . (
f3,
f4)
by A1
;
verum end;
hence
S is satisfying_commutativity
; verum