let x, y, z be set ; MMLQUER2:def 1 ( x,y in R1 \, R2 & y,z in R1 \, R2 implies x,z in R1 \, R2 )
assume A1:
( x,y in R1 \, R2 & y,z in R1 \, R2 )
; x,z in R1 \, R2
then
( [x,y] in R1 \, R2 & [y,z] in R1 \, R2 )
;
then reconsider x = x, y = y, z = z as Element of X by ZFMISC_1:87;
per cases
( ( x,y in R1 & y,z in R1 ) or ( z,x nin R1 & x,y in R2 & y,z in R2 ) or ( y,x nin R1 & z,y nin R1 & z,x in R1 ) or ( x,y in R1 & z,y nin R1 & y,z in R2 ) or ( y,z in R1 & y,x nin R1 & x,y in R2 ) )
by A1, Th9;
suppose
( (
x,
y in R1 &
y,
z in R1 ) or (
z,
x nin R1 &
x,
y in R2 &
y,
z in R2 ) )
;
x,z in R1 \, R2then
(
x,
z in R1 or (
z,
x nin R1 &
x,
z in R2 ) )
by Def1;
hence
x,
z in R1 \, R2
by Th9;
verum end; suppose A2:
(
x,
y in R1 &
z,
y nin R1 &
y,
z in R2 )
;
x,z in R1 \, R2assume
not
x,
z in R1 \, R2
;
contradictionthen
x,
z nin R1
by Th9;
hence
contradiction
by A2, Def4;
verum end; suppose A3:
(
y,
z in R1 &
y,
x nin R1 &
x,
y in R2 )
;
x,z in R1 \, R2assume
not
x,
z in R1 \, R2
;
contradictionthen
x,
z nin R1
by Th9;
hence
contradiction
by A3, Def4;
verum end; end;