let f be PartFunc of REAL,REAL; for a, b being Real
for A being non empty Subset of REAL st ].a,b.] c= dom f & A = ].a,b.] & f is_left_improper_integrable_on a,b & f | A is nonnegative holds
( left_improper_integral (f,a,b) = Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) & ( f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies f | A is_integrable_on L-Meas ) & ( not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) = +infty ) )
let a, b be Real; for A being non empty Subset of REAL st ].a,b.] c= dom f & A = ].a,b.] & f is_left_improper_integrable_on a,b & f | A is nonnegative holds
( left_improper_integral (f,a,b) = Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) & ( f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies f | A is_integrable_on L-Meas ) & ( not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) = +infty ) )
let A be non empty Subset of REAL; ( ].a,b.] c= dom f & A = ].a,b.] & f is_left_improper_integrable_on a,b & f | A is nonnegative implies ( left_improper_integral (f,a,b) = Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) & ( f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies f | A is_integrable_on L-Meas ) & ( not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) = +infty ) ) )
assume that
A1:
].a,b.] c= dom f
and
A2:
A = ].a,b.]
and
A3:
f is_left_improper_integrable_on a,b
and
A4:
f | A is nonnegative
; ( left_improper_integral (f,a,b) = Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) & ( f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies f | A is_integrable_on L-Meas ) & ( not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) = +infty ) )
reconsider A1 = A as Element of L-Field by A2, MEASUR10:5, MEASUR12:75;
A5:
a < b
by A2, XXREAL_1:26;
per cases
( f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b or not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b )
;
suppose A6:
f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,
b
;
( left_improper_integral (f,a,b) = Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) & ( f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies f | A is_integrable_on L-Meas ) & ( not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) = +infty ) )then A7:
left_improper_integral (
f,
a,
b)
= ext_left_integral (
f,
a,
b)
by A3, INTEGR24:34;
consider Intf being
PartFunc of
REAL,
REAL such that A8:
dom Intf = ].a,b.]
and A9:
for
x being
Real st
x in dom Intf holds
Intf . x = integral (
f,
x,
b)
and A10:
Intf is_right_convergent_in a
and A11:
ext_left_integral (
f,
a,
b)
= lim_right (
Intf,
a)
by A6, INTEGR10:def 4;
A12:
for
p,
q being
Real st
p in dom Intf &
q in dom Intf &
p < q holds
Intf . q <= Intf . p
proof
let p,
q be
Real;
( p in dom Intf & q in dom Intf & p < q implies Intf . q <= Intf . p )
assume that A13:
p in dom Intf
and A14:
q in dom Intf
and A15:
p < q
;
Intf . q <= Intf . p
A16:
(
a < p &
p <= b )
by A8, A13, XXREAL_1:2;
then
[.p,b.] c= ].a,b.]
by XXREAL_1:39;
then A17:
[.p,b.] c= dom f
by A1;
A18:
[.p,b.] = ['p,b']
by A16, INTEGRA5:def 3;
A19:
q <= b
by A8, A14, XXREAL_1:2;
A20:
(
f is_integrable_on ['p,b'] &
f | ['p,b'] is
bounded )
by A6, A16, INTEGR10:def 2;
(f | A) | [.p,b.] is
nonnegative
by A4, MESFUNC6:55;
then A21:
f | [.p,b.] is
nonnegative
by A2, A16, XXREAL_1:39, RELAT_1:74;
A22:
[.q,b.] c= [.p,b.]
by A15, XXREAL_1:34;
(
Intf . p = integral (
f,
p,
b) &
Intf . q = integral (
f,
q,
b) )
by A13, A14, A9;
hence
Intf . q <= Intf . p
by A17, A20, A21, A22, A19, A18, Th14;
verum
end; then A23:
Intf is
non-increasing
by RFUNCT_2:def 4;
consider E being
SetSequence of
L-Field such that A24:
( ( for
n being
Nat holds
(
E . n = [.(a + ((b - a) / (n + 1))),b.] &
E . n c= ].a,b.] &
E . n is non
empty closed_interval Subset of
REAL ) ) &
E is
non-descending &
E is
convergent &
Union E = ].a,b.] )
by A2, Th24, XXREAL_1:26;
A25:
A1 = dom (f | A1)
by A1, A2, RELAT_1:62;
then A26:
A1 = dom (R_EAL (f | A))
by MESFUNC5:def 7;
A27:
lim E = Union E
by A24, SETLIM_1:80;
A28:
lim E c= A1
by A24, A2, SETLIM_1:80;
A1 \ (lim E) = {}
by A24, A2, A27, XBOOLE_1:37;
then A29:
L-Meas . (A1 \ (lim E)) = 0
by VALUED_0:def 19;
A30:
R_EAL f is
A1 -measurable
by A1, A2, A3, Th34, MESFUNC6:def 1;
A1 = (dom f) /\ A1
by A25, RELAT_1:61;
then
A1 = (dom (R_EAL f)) /\ A1
by MESFUNC5:def 7;
then
(R_EAL f) | A is
A1 -measurable
by A30, MESFUNC5:42;
then A31:
R_EAL (f | A) is
A1 -measurable
by Th16;
A32:
R_EAL (f | A) is
nonnegative
by A4, MESFUNC5:def 7;
then A33:
integral+ (
L-Meas,
(max- (R_EAL (f | A))))
< +infty
by A31, A26, MESFUN11:53;
consider I being
ExtREAL_sequence such that A34:
for
n being
Nat holds
I . n = Integral (
L-Meas,
((R_EAL (f | A)) | ((Partial_Union E) . n)))
and
I is
convergent
and A35:
Integral (
L-Meas,
(R_EAL (f | A)))
= lim I
by A24, A31, A26, A28, A29, A33, Th19;
A36:
for
x being
Real st
x in dom Intf holds
Intf . x = Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | [.x,b.]))
proof
let x be
Real;
( x in dom Intf implies Intf . x = Integral (L-Meas,(f | [.x,b.])) )
assume A37:
x in dom Intf
;
Intf . x = Integral (L-Meas,(f | [.x,b.]))
then A38:
(
a < x &
x <= b )
by A8, XXREAL_1:2;
then A39:
(
f is_integrable_on ['x,b'] &
f | ['x,b'] is
bounded )
by A3, INTEGR24:def 1;
reconsider AX =
[.x,b.] as non
empty closed_interval Subset of
REAL by A38, XXREAL_1:30, MEASURE5:def 3;
A40:
AX = ['x,b']
by A38, INTEGRA5:def 3;
AX c= ].a,b.]
by A38, XXREAL_1:39;
then A41:
AX c= dom f
by A1;
reconsider AX1 =
AX as
Element of
L-Field by MEASUR10:5, MEASUR12:75;
AX = AX1
;
then
integral (f || AX) = Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | [.x,b.]))
by A41, A39, A40, MESFUN14:49;
then
integral (
f,
AX)
= Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | [.x,b.]))
by INTEGRA5:def 2;
then
integral (
f,
x,
b)
= Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | [.x,b.]))
by A38, A40, INTEGRA5:def 4;
hence
Intf . x = Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | [.x,b.]))
by A9, A37;
verum
end; A42:
Partial_Union E = E
by A24, PROB_4:15;
A43:
for
m being
Nat holds
I . m = integral (
f,
(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),
b)
proof
let m be
Nat;
I . m = integral (f,(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b)
A44:
(
a < a + ((b - a) / (m + 1)) &
a + ((b - a) / (m + 1)) <= b )
by A5, Th22;
then A45:
f || ['(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b'] is
bounded
by A6, INTEGR10:def 2;
A46:
['(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b'] = [.(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b.]
by A44, INTEGRA5:def 3;
then
['(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b'] c= ].a,b.]
by A44, XXREAL_1:39;
then A47:
['(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b'] c= dom f
by A1;
A48:
E . m = [.(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b.]
by A24;
(R_EAL (f | A)) | (E . m) = (f | A) | (E . m)
by MESFUNC5:def 7;
then
(R_EAL (f | A)) | (E . m) = f | (E . m)
by A24, A2, RELAT_1:74;
then A49:
(R_EAL (f | A)) | (E . m) = R_EAL (f | (E . m))
by MESFUNC5:def 7;
I . m = Integral (
L-Meas,
((R_EAL (f | A)) | ((Partial_Union E) . m)))
by A34;
then A50:
I . m = Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | [.(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b.]))
by A42, A49, A48, MESFUNC6:def 3;
f is_integrable_on ['(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b']
by A44, A6, INTEGR10:def 2;
hence
I . m = integral (
f,
(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),
b)
by A50, A44, A46, A47, A45, MESFUN14:50;
verum
end;
for
p being
Real st
0 < p holds
ex
n being
Nat st
for
m being
Nat st
n <= m holds
|.((I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b))).| < p
proof
let p be
Real;
( 0 < p implies ex n being Nat st
for m being Nat st n <= m holds
|.((I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b))).| < p )
assume
0 < p
;
ex n being Nat st
for m being Nat st n <= m holds
|.((I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b))).| < p
then consider r being
Real such that A51:
a < r
and A52:
for
r1 being
Real st
r1 < r &
a < r1 &
r1 in dom Intf holds
|.((Intf . r1) - (lim_right (Intf,a))).| < p
by A10, LIMFUNC2:42;
set rr =
min (
b,
r);
A53:
(
min (
b,
r)
<= b &
min (
b,
r)
<= r )
by XXREAL_0:17;
a < min (
b,
r)
by A5, A51, XXREAL_0:21;
then A54:
0 < (min (b,r)) - a
by XREAL_1:50;
consider n being
Nat such that A55:
(b - a) / ((min (b,r)) - a) < n
by SEQ_4:3;
n <= n + 1
by NAT_1:13;
then
(b - a) / ((min (b,r)) - a) < 1
* (n + 1)
by A55, XXREAL_0:2;
then
(b - a) / (n + 1) < 1
* ((min (b,r)) - a)
by A54, XREAL_1:113;
then
a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)) < min (
b,
r)
by XREAL_1:20;
then A56:
a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)) < r
by A53, XXREAL_0:2;
A57:
0 < b - a
by A2, XXREAL_1:26, XREAL_1:50;
A58:
(
a < a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)) &
a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)) <= b )
by A5, Th22;
then A59:
a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)) in dom Intf
by A8, XXREAL_1:2;
set r1 =
a + ((b - a) / (n + 1));
A60:
|.((Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)))) - (lim_right (Intf,a))).| < p
by A52, A56, A59, A58;
take
n
;
for m being Nat st n <= m holds
|.((I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b))).| < p
thus
for
m being
Nat st
n <= m holds
|.((I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b))).| < p
verumproof
let m be
Nat;
( n <= m implies |.((I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b))).| < p )
set rm =
a + ((b - a) / (m + 1));
assume
n <= m
;
|.((I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b))).| < p
then
n + 1
<= m + 1
by XREAL_1:6;
then
(b - a) / (n + 1) >= (b - a) / (m + 1)
by A57, XREAL_1:118;
then A61:
a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)) >= a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))
by XREAL_1:6;
A62:
a + ((b - a) / (m + 1)) <= b
by A5, Th22;
A63:
a < a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))
by A57, XREAL_1:29;
then
[.(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b.] c= ].a,b.]
by XXREAL_1:39;
then A64:
[.(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b.] c= dom f
by A1;
f | ['(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b'] is
bounded
by A62, A63, A3, INTEGR24:def 1;
then A65:
f | [.(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b.] is
bounded
by A61, A58, XXREAL_0:2, INTEGRA5:def 3;
A66:
f is_integrable_on ['(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b']
by A62, A63, A3, INTEGR24:def 1;
(f | A) | [.(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b.] is
nonnegative
by A4, MESFUNC6:55;
then A67:
f | [.(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b.] is
nonnegative
by A2, A63, XXREAL_1:39, RELAT_1:74;
[.(a + ((b - a) / (n + 1))),b.] c= [.(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),b.]
by A61, XXREAL_1:34;
then
integral (
f,
(a + ((b - a) / (n + 1))),
b)
<= integral (
f,
(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),
b)
by A58, A64, A65, A66, A67, Th14;
then
Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1))) <= integral (
f,
(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),
b)
by A9, A58, A8, XXREAL_1:2;
then A68:
Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1))) <= I . m
by A43;
A69:
a + ((b - a) / (m + 1)) in dom Intf
by A8, A62, A63, XXREAL_1:2;
Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))) = integral (
f,
(a + ((b - a) / (m + 1))),
b)
by A9, A8, A62, A63, XXREAL_1:2;
then
I . m = Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (m + 1)))
by A43;
then
I . m <= lim_right (
Intf,
a)
by A10, A23, A69, Th9, A57, XREAL_1:29;
then A70:
(lim_right (Intf,a)) - (I . m) >= 0
by XXREAL_3:40;
then
- ((lim_right (Intf,a)) - (I . m)) <= 0
;
then
(I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b)) <= 0
by A11, XXREAL_3:26;
then A71:
|.((I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b))).| =
- ((I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b)))
by EXTREAL1:18
.=
(ext_left_integral (f,a,b)) - (I . m)
by XXREAL_3:26
;
reconsider EX =
ext_left_integral (
f,
a,
b) as
ExtReal ;
A72:
EX - (Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)))) =
EX + (- (Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)))))
by XXREAL_3:def 4
.=
(ext_left_integral (f,a,b)) + (- (Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)))))
by XXREAL_3:def 2
.=
(ext_left_integral (f,a,b)) - (Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1))))
;
A73:
EX - (I . m) <= EX - (Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1))))
by A68, XXREAL_3:37;
then
- ((ext_left_integral (f,a,b)) - (Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1))))) <= 0
by A72, A70, A11;
then
|.((Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)))) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b))).| = - ((Intf . (a + ((b - a) / (n + 1)))) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b)))
by ABSVALUE:30;
hence
|.((I . m) - (ext_left_integral (f,a,b))).| < p
by A60, A11, A72, A73, A71, XXREAL_0:2;
verum
end;
end; then consider RI being
Real such that A74:
(
lim I = RI & ( for
p being
Real st
0 < p holds
ex
n being
Nat st
for
m being
Nat st
n <= m holds
|.((I . m) - (lim I)).| < p ) )
by MESFUNC5:def 8, MESFUNC9:7;
A75:
RI = Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | A))
by A35, A74, MESFUNC6:def 3;
for
g1 being
Real st
0 < g1 holds
ex
R being
Real st
(
a < R & ( for
r1 being
Real st
r1 < R &
a < r1 &
r1 in dom Intf holds
|.((Intf . r1) - RI).| < g1 ) )
proof
let g1 be
Real;
( 0 < g1 implies ex R being Real st
( a < R & ( for r1 being Real st r1 < R & a < r1 & r1 in dom Intf holds
|.((Intf . r1) - RI).| < g1 ) ) )
assume A76:
0 < g1
;
ex R being Real st
( a < R & ( for r1 being Real st r1 < R & a < r1 & r1 in dom Intf holds
|.((Intf . r1) - RI).| < g1 ) )
set g2 =
g1 / 2;
consider N being
Nat such that A77:
for
m being
Nat st
N <= m holds
|.((I . m) - (lim I)).| < g1
by A76, A74;
take R =
a + ((b - a) / (N + 1));
( a < R & ( for r1 being Real st r1 < R & a < r1 & r1 in dom Intf holds
|.((Intf . r1) - RI).| < g1 ) )
A78:
(
a < R &
R <= b )
by A5, Th22;
then A79:
R in dom Intf
by A8, XXREAL_1:2;
thus
a < R
by A5, Th22;
for r1 being Real st r1 < R & a < r1 & r1 in dom Intf holds
|.((Intf . r1) - RI).| < g1
thus
for
r1 being
Real st
r1 < R &
a < r1 &
r1 in dom Intf holds
|.((Intf . r1) - RI).| < g1
verumproof
let r1 be
Real;
( r1 < R & a < r1 & r1 in dom Intf implies |.((Intf . r1) - RI).| < g1 )
assume that A80:
r1 < R
and A81:
a < r1
and A82:
r1 in dom Intf
;
|.((Intf . r1) - RI).| < g1
I . N = integral (
f,
(a + ((b - a) / (N + 1))),
b)
by A43;
then A83:
Intf . R = I . N
by A78, A9, A8, XXREAL_1:2;
A84:
I . N <= Intf . r1
by A80, A79, A82, A12, A83;
(
RI - (I . N) = RI - (I . N) &
RI - (Intf . r1) = RI - (Intf . r1) )
;
then A85:
RI - (Intf . r1) <= RI - (I . N)
by A84, XXREAL_3:37;
A86:
|.((I . N) - RI).| < g1
by A77, A74;
reconsider A2 =
[.r1,b.] as
Element of
L-Field by MEASUR10:5, MEASUR12:75;
A2 c= A1
by A2, A81, XXREAL_1:39;
then
Integral (
L-Meas,
((f | A) | A2))
<= Integral (
L-Meas,
((f | A) | A1))
by A25, A31, A4, MESFUNC6:def 1, MESFUNC6:87;
then
Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | A2))
<= RI
by A75, A2, A81, XXREAL_1:39, RELAT_1:74;
then A87:
Intf . r1 <= RI
by A82, A36;
then A88:
|.((Intf . r1) - RI).| = - ((Intf . r1) - RI)
by ABSVALUE:30, XREAL_1:47;
I . N <= RI
by A84, A87, XXREAL_0:2;
then
|.(RI - (I . N)).| = RI - (I . N)
by EXTREAL1:def 1, XXREAL_3:40;
then
|.(- (RI - (I . N))).| = RI - (I . N)
by EXTREAL1:29;
then
|.((I . N) - RI).| = RI - (I . N)
by XXREAL_3:26;
hence
|.((Intf . r1) - RI).| < g1
by A85, A88, A86, XXREAL_0:2;
verum
end;
end; hence
left_improper_integral (
f,
a,
b)
= Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | A))
by A11, A7, A75, A10, LIMFUNC2:42;
( ( f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies f | A is_integrable_on L-Meas ) & ( not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) = +infty ) )
max+ (R_EAL (f | A)) = R_EAL (f | A)
by A32, MESFUN11:31;
then
Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | A))
= integral+ (
L-Meas,
(max+ (R_EAL (f | A))))
by A31, A25, A4, MESFUNC6:def 1, MESFUNC6:82;
then
integral+ (
L-Meas,
(max+ (R_EAL (f | A))))
< +infty
by A75, XREAL_0:def 1, XXREAL_0:9;
hence
(
f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,
b implies
f | A is_integrable_on L-Meas )
by A31, A26, A33, MESFUNC5:def 17, MESFUNC6:def 4;
( not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) = +infty )thus
( not
f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,
b implies
Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | A))
= +infty )
by A6;
verum end; suppose A89:
not
f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,
b
;
( left_improper_integral (f,a,b) = Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) & ( f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies f | A is_integrable_on L-Meas ) & ( not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) = +infty ) )hence
left_improper_integral (
f,
a,
b)
= Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | A))
by A1, A2, A3, A4, Lm7;
( ( f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies f | A is_integrable_on L-Meas ) & ( not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) = +infty ) )thus
(
f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,
b implies
f | A is_integrable_on L-Meas )
by A89;
( not f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,b implies Integral (L-Meas,(f | A)) = +infty )thus
( not
f is_left_ext_Riemann_integrable_on a,
b implies
Integral (
L-Meas,
(f | A))
= +infty )
by A1, A2, A3, A4, Lm7;
verum end; end;