let f be PartFunc of REAL,REAL; for a, b, c being Real st a <= b & b < c & [.a,c.[ c= dom f & f | ['a,b'] is bounded & f is_right_improper_integrable_on b,c & f is_integrable_on ['a,b'] & right_improper_integral (f,b,c) = -infty holds
( f is_right_improper_integrable_on a,c & right_improper_integral (f,a,c) = -infty )
let a, b, c be Real; ( a <= b & b < c & [.a,c.[ c= dom f & f | ['a,b'] is bounded & f is_right_improper_integrable_on b,c & f is_integrable_on ['a,b'] & right_improper_integral (f,b,c) = -infty implies ( f is_right_improper_integrable_on a,c & right_improper_integral (f,a,c) = -infty ) )
assume that
A1:
( a <= b & b < c )
and
A2:
[.a,c.[ c= dom f
and
A3:
f | ['a,b'] is bounded
and
A4:
f is_right_improper_integrable_on b,c
and
A5:
f is_integrable_on ['a,b']
and
A6:
right_improper_integral (f,b,c) = -infty
; ( f is_right_improper_integrable_on a,c & right_improper_integral (f,a,c) = -infty )
consider I being PartFunc of REAL,REAL such that
A7:
dom I = [.b,c.[
and
A8:
for x being Real st x in dom I holds
I . x = integral (f,b,x)
and
A9:
( I is_left_convergent_in c or I is_left_divergent_to+infty_in c or I is_left_divergent_to-infty_in c )
by A4;
right_improper_integral (f,b,c) <> ext_right_integral (f,b,c)
by A6;
then A10:
not f is_right_ext_Riemann_integrable_on b,c
by A4, Th39;
reconsider AC = [.a,c.[ as non empty Subset of REAL by A1, XXREAL_1:3;
deffunc H1( Element of AC) -> Element of REAL = In ((integral (f,a,$1)),REAL);
consider Intf being Function of AC,REAL such that
A11:
for x being Element of AC holds Intf . x = H1(x)
from FUNCT_2:sch 4();
A12:
dom Intf = AC
by FUNCT_2:def 1;
then reconsider Intf = Intf as PartFunc of REAL,REAL by RELSET_1:5;
A13:
for x being Real st x in dom Intf holds
Intf . x = integral (f,a,x)
proof
let x be
Real;
( x in dom Intf implies Intf . x = integral (f,a,x) )
assume
x in dom Intf
;
Intf . x = integral (f,a,x)
then
Intf . x = In (
(integral (f,a,x)),
REAL)
by A11, A12;
hence
Intf . x = integral (
f,
a,
x)
;
verum
end;
A14:
for r being Real st r < c holds
ex g being Real st
( r < g & g < c & g in dom Intf )
proof
let r be
Real;
( r < c implies ex g being Real st
( r < g & g < c & g in dom Intf ) )
assume
r < c
;
ex g being Real st
( r < g & g < c & g in dom Intf )
then consider g being
Real such that A15:
(
r < g &
g < c &
g in dom I )
by A10, A6, A7, Def4, INTEGR10:def 1, A4, LIMFUNC2:9;
[.b,c.[ c= [.a,c.[
by A1, XXREAL_1:38;
hence
ex
g being
Real st
(
r < g &
g < c &
g in dom Intf )
by A15, A7, A12;
verum
end;
A16:
for g1 being Real ex r being Real st
( r < c & ( for r1 being Real st r < r1 & r1 < c & r1 in dom Intf holds
Intf . r1 < g1 ) )
proof
let g1 be
Real;
ex r being Real st
( r < c & ( for r1 being Real st r < r1 & r1 < c & r1 in dom Intf holds
Intf . r1 < g1 ) )
consider r being
Real such that A17:
r < c
and A18:
for
r1 being
Real st
r < r1 &
r1 < c &
r1 in dom I holds
I . r1 < g1 - (integral (f,a,b))
by A10, A9, A4, A6, A7, A8, Def4, INTEGR10:def 1, LIMFUNC2:9;
set R =
max (
b,
r);
take
max (
b,
r)
;
( max (b,r) < c & ( for r1 being Real st max (b,r) < r1 & r1 < c & r1 in dom Intf holds
Intf . r1 < g1 ) )
thus
max (
b,
r)
< c
by A1, A17, XXREAL_0:29;
for r1 being Real st max (b,r) < r1 & r1 < c & r1 in dom Intf holds
Intf . r1 < g1
thus
for
r1 being
Real st
max (
b,
r)
< r1 &
r1 < c &
r1 in dom Intf holds
Intf . r1 < g1
verumproof
let r1 be
Real;
( max (b,r) < r1 & r1 < c & r1 in dom Intf implies Intf . r1 < g1 )
assume A19:
(
max (
b,
r)
< r1 &
r1 < c &
r1 in dom Intf )
;
Intf . r1 < g1
(
b <= max (
b,
r) &
r <= max (
b,
r) )
by XXREAL_0:25;
then A20:
(
b < r1 &
r < r1 )
by A19, XXREAL_0:2;
then A21:
a < r1
by A1, XXREAL_0:2;
r1 in dom I
by A7, A19, A20, XXREAL_1:3;
then
I . r1 < g1 - (integral (f,a,b))
by A18, A19, A20;
then A22:
integral (
f,
b,
r1)
< g1 - (integral (f,a,b))
by A8, A20, A7, A19, XXREAL_1:3;
A23:
(
f is_integrable_on ['a,r1'] &
f | ['a,r1'] is
bounded )
by A19, A21, A1, A2, A3, A4, A5, Lm19;
A24:
['a,r1'] = [.a,r1.]
by A20, A1, XXREAL_0:2, INTEGRA5:def 3;
then
['a,r1'] c= [.a,c.[
by A19, XXREAL_1:43;
then A25:
['a,r1'] c= dom f
by A2;
b in ['a,r1']
by A24, A20, A1, XXREAL_1:1;
then
integral (
f,
a,
r1)
= (integral (f,a,b)) + (integral (f,b,r1))
by A21, A23, A25, INTEGRA6:17;
then
integral (
f,
b,
r1)
= (integral (f,a,r1)) - (integral (f,a,b))
;
then
integral (
f,
a,
r1)
< g1
by A22, XREAL_1:9;
hence
Intf . r1 < g1
by A13, A19;
verum
end;
end;
hence A26:
f is_right_improper_integrable_on a,c
by A12, A13, A14, A1, A2, A3, A4, A5, Lm19, LIMFUNC2:9; right_improper_integral (f,a,c) = -infty
Intf is_left_divergent_to-infty_in c
by A14, A16, LIMFUNC2:9;
hence
right_improper_integral (f,a,c) = -infty
by A12, A13, A26, Def4; verum