let S be IncSpace; for A being POINT of S
for L being LINE of S ex P being PLANE of S st
( A on P & not L on P )
let A be POINT of S; for L being LINE of S ex P being PLANE of S st
( A on P & not L on P )
let L be LINE of S; ex P being PLANE of S st
( A on P & not L on P )
consider B being POINT of S such that
A1:
A <> B
and
A2:
B on L
by Lm1;
consider C, D being POINT of S such that
A3:
not {A,B,C,D} is planar
by A1, Th47;
take P = Plane (A,C,D); ( A on P & not L on P )
A4:
not {A,C,D,B} is planar
by A3, ENUMSET1:63;
then
not {A,C,D} is linear
by Th17;
then A5:
{A,C,D} on P
by Def20;
hence
A on P
by Th4; not L on P
( B on P implies {A,C,D} \/ {B} on P )
by A5, Th9;
then
( B on P implies {A,C,D,B} on P )
by ENUMSET1:6;
hence
not L on P
by A2, A4, Def17; verum