let S be IncSpace; for L, L1, L2 being LINE of S
for P being PLANE of S st L1 on P & L2 on P & not L on P & L1 <> L2 holds
for Q being PLANE of S holds
( not L on Q or not L1 on Q or not L2 on Q )
let L, L1, L2 be LINE of S; for P being PLANE of S st L1 on P & L2 on P & not L on P & L1 <> L2 holds
for Q being PLANE of S holds
( not L on Q or not L1 on Q or not L2 on Q )
let P be PLANE of S; ( L1 on P & L2 on P & not L on P & L1 <> L2 implies for Q being PLANE of S holds
( not L on Q or not L1 on Q or not L2 on Q ) )
assume that
A1:
L1 on P
and
A2:
L2 on P
and
A3:
not L on P
and
A4:
L1 <> L2
; for Q being PLANE of S holds
( not L on Q or not L1 on Q or not L2 on Q )
consider A, B being POINT of S such that
A5:
A <> B
and
A6:
{A,B} on L1
by Def8;
A7:
{A,B} on P
by A1, A6, Th14;
consider C, C1 being POINT of S such that
A8:
C <> C1
and
A9:
{C,C1} on L2
by Def8;
A10:
now ( C on L1 implies not C1 on L1 )assume
(
C on L1 &
C1 on L1 )
;
contradictionthen
{C,C1} on L1
by Th1;
hence
contradiction
by A4, A8, A9, Def10;
verum end;
A11:
{C,C1} on P
by A2, A9, Th14;
then
C on P
by Th3;
then
{A,B} \/ {C} on P
by A7, Th9;
then A12:
{A,B,C} on P
by ENUMSET1:3;
C1 on P
by A11, Th3;
then
{A,B} \/ {C1} on P
by A7, Th9;
then A13:
{A,B,C1} on P
by ENUMSET1:3;
consider D, E being POINT of S such that
A14:
D <> E
and
A15:
{D,E} on L
by Def8;
given Q being PLANE of S such that A16:
L on Q
and
A17:
L1 on Q
and
A18:
L2 on Q
; contradiction
A19:
{A,B} on Q
by A17, A6, Th14;
A20:
{C,C1} on Q
by A18, A9, Th14;
then A21:
C on Q
by Th3;
A22:
{D,E} on Q
by A16, A15, Th14;
then A23:
D on Q
by Th3;
then
{C,D} on Q
by A21, Th3;
then
{A,B} \/ {C,D} on Q
by A19, Th11;
then
{A,B,C,D} on Q
by ENUMSET1:5;
then A24:
{A,B,C,D} is planar
;
A25:
E on Q
by A22, Th3;
then
{C,E} on Q
by A21, Th3;
then
{A,B} \/ {C,E} on Q
by A19, Th11;
then
{A,B,C,E} on Q
by ENUMSET1:5;
then A26:
{A,B,C,E} is planar
;
A27:
C1 on Q
by A20, Th3;
then
{C1,D} on Q
by A23, Th3;
then
{A,B} \/ {C1,D} on Q
by A19, Th11;
then
{A,B,C1,D} on Q
by ENUMSET1:5;
then A28:
{A,B,C1,D} is planar
;
{C1,E} on Q
by A27, A25, Th3;
then
{A,B} \/ {C1,E} on Q
by A19, Th11;
then
{A,B,C1,E} on Q
by ENUMSET1:5;
then A29:
{A,B,C1,E} is planar
;
not {D,E} on P
by A3, A14, A15, Def14;
then
( not D on P or not E on P )
by Th3;
hence
contradiction
by A5, A6, A24, A26, A28, A29, A10, A12, A13, Th18, Th19; verum