let n, k, p be Nat; ( 0 < k & (2 * k) |^ k <= n & n |^ k < p implies ( ((p + 1) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1)) > 0 & k ! < (((n + 1) |^ k) * (p |^ k)) / (((p + 1) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1))) & (((n + 1) |^ k) * (p |^ k)) / (((p + 1) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1))) < (k !) + 1 ) )
set k1 = k + 1;
set n1 = n + 1;
assume A1:
( 0 < k & (2 * k) |^ k <= n & n |^ k < p )
; ( ((p + 1) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1)) > 0 & k ! < (((n + 1) |^ k) * (p |^ k)) / (((p + 1) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1))) & (((n + 1) |^ k) * (p |^ k)) / (((p + 1) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1))) < (k !) + 1 )
then A2:
1 <= k
by NAT_1:14;
(2 * k) |^ k >= (2 * k) |^ 1
by A1, NAT_6:1, NAT_1:14;
then A3:
( 2 * k <= n & k + 0 < k + k )
by A1, XXREAL_0:2, XREAL_1:8;
then A4:
( n <> 0 & k < n )
by XXREAL_0:2;
then A5:
( k <= n & 1 <= n & k + 1 <= n )
by NAT_1:13, NAT_1:14;
then A6:
( k < n + 1 & k + 1 <= n + 1 )
by NAT_1:13;
n |^ k >= 1
by A4, NAT_1:14;
then
1 < p
by A1, XXREAL_0:2;
then A7:
1 + 1 <= p
by NAT_1:13;
reconsider K = k - 1, nk = n - k as Nat by A3, XXREAL_0:2, A1, NAT_1:21;
set P = (1,p) In_Power n;
A8:
len ((1,p) In_Power n) = n + 1
by NEWTON:def 4;
A9:
Sum ((1,p) In_Power n) = (1 + p) |^ n
by NEWTON:30;
A10:
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)), Sum ((1,p) In_Power n) are_congruent_mod p |^ (k + 1)
proof
defpred S1[
Nat]
means (
k + 1
<= $1 & $1
<= len ((1,p) In_Power n) implies
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)),
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | $1) are_congruent_mod p |^ (k + 1) );
A11:
S1[
0 ]
;
A12:
for
i being
Nat st
S1[
i] holds
S1[
i + 1]
proof
let i be
Nat;
( S1[i] implies S1[i + 1] )
set i1 =
i + 1;
assume that A13:
S1[
i]
and A14:
(
k + 1
<= i + 1 &
i + 1
<= len ((1,p) In_Power n) )
;
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)), Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1)) are_congruent_mod p |^ (k + 1)
per cases
( k + 1 = i + 1 or k + 1 < i + 1 )
by A14, XXREAL_0:1;
suppose A15:
k + 1
< i + 1
;
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)), Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1)) are_congruent_mod p |^ (k + 1)then A16:
(
k + 1
<= i &
i <= len ((1,p) In_Power n) )
by A14, NAT_1:13;
reconsider ni =
n - i as
Nat by A14, A8, NAT_1:21, XREAL_1:8;
A17:
i + 1
in dom ((1,p) In_Power n)
by A14, FINSEQ_3:25, NAT_1:11;
then A18:
((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1) = (((1,p) In_Power n) | i) ^ <*(((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1))*>
by FINSEQ_5:10;
(
(i + 1) - 1
= i &
n - i = ni )
;
then A19:
((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1) = ((n choose i) * (1 |^ ni)) * (p |^ i)
by A17, NEWTON:def 4;
p |^ (k + 1) divides (((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1)) - 0
by A16, A19, INT_2:2, NEWTON:89;
then
0 ,
((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1) are_congruent_mod p |^ (k + 1)
by INT_1:14, INT_1:def 4;
then
(Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1))) + 0,
(Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | i)) + (((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1)) are_congruent_mod p |^ (k + 1)
by A13, A15, A14, NAT_1:13, INT_1:16;
hence
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)),
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1)) are_congruent_mod p |^ (k + 1)
by A18, RVSUM_1:74;
verum end; end;
end;
for
i being
Nat holds
S1[
i]
from NAT_1:sch 2(A11, A12);
then
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)),
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (len ((1,p) In_Power n))) are_congruent_mod p |^ (k + 1)
by A6, A8;
hence
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)),
Sum ((1,p) In_Power n) are_congruent_mod p |^ (k + 1)
;
verum
end;
A20:
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)) <> 0
proof
assume
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)) = 0
;
contradiction
then
p |^ (k + 1) divides 0 - (Sum ((1,p) In_Power n))
by A10, INT_1:def 4;
then
p |^ (k + 1) divides - ((1 + p) |^ n)
by A9;
then A21:
p |^ (k + 1) divides (1 + p) |^ n
by INT_2:10;
(1 + p) |^ n,
p |^ n are_coprime
by PEPIN:1, WSIERP_1:11;
then A22:
((1 + p) |^ n) gcd (p |^ n) = 1
by INT_2:def 3;
p |^ (k + 1) divides p |^ n
by A5, NEWTON:89;
then
p |^ (k + 1) divides 1
by A21, A22, INT_2:def 2;
then
(
p |^ (k + 1) = 1 &
p |^ (k + 1) > k + 1 )
by A7, NEWTON:86, INT_2:13;
hence
contradiction
by NAT_1:14;
verum
end;
A23:
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)) < p |^ (k + 1)
proof
defpred S1[
Nat]
means ( $1
<= k + 1 implies
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | $1) < p |^ $1 );
(n |^ k) + 1
<= p
by A1, NAT_1:13;
then A24:
n |^ k <= p - 1
by XREAL_1:19;
reconsider p1 =
p - 1 as
Nat by A1;
A25:
S1[
0 ]
;
A26:
for
i being
Nat st
S1[
i] holds
S1[
i + 1]
proof
let i be
Nat;
( S1[i] implies S1[i + 1] )
set i1 =
i + 1;
assume A27:
(
S1[
i] &
i + 1
<= k + 1 )
;
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1)) < p |^ (i + 1)
then A28:
i < k + 1
by NAT_1:13;
A29:
i + 1
<= n + 1
by A6, A27, XXREAL_0:2;
then A30:
i <= n
by XREAL_1:8;
reconsider ni =
n - i as
Nat by A29, XREAL_1:8, NAT_1:21;
( 1
<= i + 1 &
i + 1
<= len ((1,p) In_Power n) )
by A6, A8, A27, XXREAL_0:2, NAT_1:11;
then A31:
i + 1
in dom ((1,p) In_Power n)
by FINSEQ_3:25;
then A32:
((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1) = (((1,p) In_Power n) | i) ^ <*(((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1))*>
by FINSEQ_5:10;
(
(i + 1) - 1
= i &
n - i = ni )
;
then A33:
((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1) = ((n choose i) * (1 |^ ni)) * (p |^ i)
by A31, NEWTON:def 4;
i <= k
by A28, NAT_1:13;
then A34:
n |^ i <= n |^ k
by A4, NAT_6:1;
n choose i <= n |^ i
by A30, HILB10_4:13;
then
n choose i <= n |^ k
by A34, XXREAL_0:2;
then
n choose i <= p - 1
by A24, XXREAL_0:2;
then
((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1) <= p1 * (p |^ i)
by A33, XREAL_1:66;
then A35:
(Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | i)) + (((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1)) < (p |^ i) + (p1 * (p |^ i))
by NAT_1:13, A27, XREAL_1:8;
(p |^ i) + (p1 * (p |^ i)) =
p * (p |^ i)
.=
p |^ (i + 1)
by NEWTON:6
;
hence
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1)) < p |^ (i + 1)
by A32, RVSUM_1:74, A35;
verum
end;
for
i being
Nat holds
S1[
i]
from NAT_1:sch 2(A25, A26);
hence
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)) < p |^ (k + 1)
;
verum
end;
(Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1))) mod (p |^ (k + 1)) = (Sum ((1,p) In_Power n)) mod (p |^ (k + 1))
by A10, NAT_D:64;
then
(Sum ((1,p) In_Power n)) mod (p |^ (k + 1)) = Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1))
by A23, NAT_D:24;
then A36:
((1 + p) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1)) = Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1))
by NEWTON:30;
( 1 <= k + 1 & k + 1 <= len ((1,p) In_Power n) )
by A5, NAT_1:13, A8, NAT_1:11;
then A37:
k + 1 in dom ((1,p) In_Power n)
by FINSEQ_3:25;
then
((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1) = (((1,p) In_Power n) | k) ^ <*(((1,p) In_Power n) . (k + 1))*>
by FINSEQ_5:10;
then A38:
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)) = (Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | k)) + (((1,p) In_Power n) . (k + 1))
by RVSUM_1:74;
( (k + 1) - 1 = k & n - k = nk )
;
then A39:
((1,p) In_Power n) . (k + 1) = ((n choose k) * (1 |^ nk)) * (p |^ k)
by A37, NEWTON:def 4;
n choose k <= (n |^ k) / (k !)
by A4, Th8;
then
((1,p) In_Power n) . (k + 1) <= ((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ k)
by A39, XREAL_1:66;
then A40:
((1,p) In_Power n) . (k + 1) <= ((p |^ k) * (n |^ k)) / (k !)
by XCMPLX_1:74;
A41:
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | k) <= (((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ K)) * k
proof
defpred S1[
Nat]
means ( $1
<= k implies
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | $1) <= (((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ K)) * $1 );
A42:
S1[
0 ]
;
A43:
for
i being
Nat st
S1[
i] holds
S1[
i + 1]
proof
let i be
Nat;
( S1[i] implies S1[i + 1] )
set i1 =
i + 1;
assume A44:
(
S1[
i] &
i + 1
<= k )
;
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1)) <= (((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ K)) * (i + 1)
then A45:
(
i < k &
k = K + 1 )
by NAT_1:13;
then reconsider ni =
n - i as
Nat by NAT_1:21, A4, XXREAL_0:2;
A46:
i + 1
<= n + 1
by A44, A6, XXREAL_0:2;
1
<= i + 1
by NAT_1:11;
then A47:
i + 1
in dom ((1,p) In_Power n)
by A46, A8, FINSEQ_3:25;
then
((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1) = (((1,p) In_Power n) | i) ^ <*(((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1))*>
by FINSEQ_5:10;
then A48:
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1)) = (Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | i)) + (((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1))
by RVSUM_1:74;
(
(i + 1) - 1
= i &
n - i = ni )
;
then A49:
((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1) = ((n choose i) * (1 |^ ni)) * (p |^ i)
by A47, NEWTON:def 4;
A50:
i <= K
by A45, NAT_1:13;
then A51:
p |^ i <= p |^ K
by NAT_6:1, A1;
2
* K <= (2 * K) + 2
by NAT_1:11;
then
2
* K <= n
by A3, XXREAL_0:2;
then
2
* K < n + 1
by NAT_1:13;
then A52:
n choose i <= n choose K
by Th9, A50;
A53:
(
(n |^ K) * k <= (n |^ K) * n &
(n |^ K) * n = n |^ (K + 1) )
by A4, XREAL_1:66, NEWTON:6;
A54:
(K !) * (K + 1) = k !
by NEWTON:15;
k / k = 1
by A1, XCMPLX_1:60;
then (n |^ K) / (K !) =
((n |^ K) / (K !)) * (k / k)
.=
((n |^ K) * k) / (k !)
by A54, XCMPLX_1:76
;
then A55:
(n |^ K) / (K !) <= (n |^ (K + 1)) / (k !)
by A53, XREAL_1:72;
(
K + 1
= k &
k <= n )
by A3, XXREAL_0:2;
then
K < n
by NAT_1:13;
then
n choose K <= (n |^ K) / (K !)
by Th8;
then
n choose i <= (n |^ K) / (K !)
by A52, XXREAL_0:2;
then
n choose i <= (n |^ k) / (k !)
by A55, XXREAL_0:2;
then
((1,p) In_Power n) . (i + 1) <= ((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ K)
by A49, A51, XREAL_1:66;
then
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1)) <= ((((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ K)) * i) + (((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ K))
by A48, A44, NAT_1:13, XREAL_1:7;
hence
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (i + 1)) <= (((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ K)) * (i + 1)
;
verum
end;
for
i being
Nat holds
S1[
i]
from NAT_1:sch 2(A42, A43);
hence
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | k) <= (((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ K)) * k
;
verum
end;
(p |^ K) * p = p |^ (K + 1)
by NEWTON:6;
then
((p |^ K) * k) * p = k * (p |^ k)
;
then A56:
((p |^ K) * k) * (n |^ k) < k * (p |^ k)
by A1, XREAL_1:68;
(((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ K)) * k =
((n |^ k) / (k !)) * ((p |^ K) * k)
.=
(((p |^ K) * k) * (n |^ k)) / (k !)
by XCMPLX_1:74
;
then
(((n |^ k) / (k !)) * (p |^ K)) * k < (k * (p |^ k)) / (k !)
by A56, XREAL_1:74;
then
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | k) < (k * (p |^ k)) / (k !)
by A41, XXREAL_0:2;
then
(Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | k)) + (((1,p) In_Power n) . (k + 1)) < ((k * (p |^ k)) / (k !)) + (((p |^ k) * (n |^ k)) / (k !))
by A40, XREAL_1:8;
then
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)) < ((k * (p |^ k)) + ((p |^ k) * (n |^ k))) / (k !)
by A38, XCMPLX_1:62;
then
(k !) * (Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1))) < (k !) * (((k * (p |^ k)) + ((p |^ k) * (n |^ k))) / (k !))
by XREAL_1:68;
then A57:
(k !) * (Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1))) < (k + (n |^ k)) * (p |^ k)
by XCMPLX_1:87;
k + (n |^ k) <= (1 + n) |^ k
by A4, Lm2;
then
(k + (n |^ k)) * (p |^ k) <= ((1 + n) |^ k) * (p |^ k)
by XREAL_1:66;
then
(k !) * (Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1))) < ((1 + n) |^ k) * (p |^ k)
by A57, XXREAL_0:2;
hence
( ((p + 1) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1)) > 0 & k ! < (((n + 1) |^ k) * (p |^ k)) / (((p + 1) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1))) )
by A36, A20, XREAL_1:81; (((n + 1) |^ k) * (p |^ k)) / (((p + 1) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1))) < (k !) + 1
A58:
(n + 1) - k > 0
by A6, XREAL_1:50;
n choose k >= (((n + 1) - k) |^ k) / (k !)
by Th7, A4;
then A59:
((n + 1) |^ k) / (n choose k) <= ((n + 1) |^ k) / ((((n + 1) - k) |^ k) / (k !))
by A58, XREAL_1:118;
A60:
((n + 1) |^ k) / ((((n + 1) - k) |^ k) / (k !)) = (k !) * (((n + 1) |^ k) / (((n + 1) - k) |^ k))
by XCMPLX_1:81;
A61:
( (n + 1) / (n + 1) > k / (n + 1) & (n + 1) / (n + 1) = 1 )
by A6, XCMPLX_1:60, XREAL_1:74;
((n + 1) - k) / (n + 1) =
((n + 1) / (n + 1)) - (k / (n + 1))
by XCMPLX_1:120
.=
1 - (k / (n + 1))
by XCMPLX_1:60
;
then
(((n + 1) - k) |^ k) / ((n + 1) |^ k) = (1 - (k / (n + 1))) |^ k
by PREPOWER:8;
then A62:
((n + 1) |^ k) / (((n + 1) - k) |^ k) = 1 / ((1 - (k / (n + 1))) |^ k)
by XCMPLX_1:57;
A63:
( k * k <= n & (2 * k) * k <= n + 1 )
then
k * k < n + 1
by NAT_1:13;
then
1 > (k * k) / (n + 1)
by A61, XREAL_1:74;
then A66:
0 < 1 - ((k * k) / (n + 1))
by XREAL_1:50;
1 - ((k * k) / (n + 1)) <= (1 - (k / (n + 1))) |^ k
by Lm3, A6;
then
((n + 1) |^ k) / (((n + 1) - k) |^ k) <= 1 / (1 - ((k * k) / (n + 1)))
by A62, A66, XREAL_1:118;
then
(k !) * (((n + 1) |^ k) / (((n + 1) - k) |^ k)) <= (k !) * (1 / (1 - ((k * k) / (n + 1))))
by XREAL_1:64;
then A67:
((n + 1) |^ k) / (n choose k) <= (k !) * (1 / (1 - ((k * k) / (n + 1))))
by A59, A60, XXREAL_0:2;
( n + 1 > (2 * k) |^ k & (2 * k) * k > 0 & (2 * k) |^ k > 0 )
by A1, NAT_1:13;
then
((2 * k) * k) / (n + 1) < ((2 * k) * k) / ((2 * k) |^ k)
by XREAL_1:76;
then A68:
1 + (((2 * k) * k) / (n + 1)) < 1 + (((2 * k) * k) / ((2 * k) |^ k))
by XREAL_1:8;
1 / (1 - ((k * k) / (n + 1))) <= 1 + ((2 * (k * k)) / (n + 1))
by Lm5, A1, A63;
then
1 / (1 - ((k * k) / (n + 1))) < 1 + ((2 * (k * k)) / ((2 * k) |^ k))
by A68, XXREAL_0:2;
then
(k !) * (1 / (1 - ((k * k) / (n + 1)))) < (k !) * (1 + ((2 * (k * k)) / ((2 * k) |^ k)))
by XREAL_1:68;
then A69:
((n + 1) |^ k) / (n choose k) < (k !) * (1 + ((2 * (k * k)) / ((2 * k) |^ k)))
by A67, XXREAL_0:2;
A70: (k !) * (1 + (1 / (k !))) =
((k !) * 1) + ((k !) * (1 / (k !)))
.=
(k !) + ((k !) / (k !))
by XCMPLX_1:74
.=
(k !) + 1
by XCMPLX_1:60
;
A71:
n choose k <> 0
by CATALAN2:26, A4;
A72:
k * k = k ^2
by SQUARE_1:def 1;
1 * ((2 * k) |^ k) >= (2 * (k ^2)) * (k !)
then
1 / (k !) >= (2 * (k ^2)) / ((2 * k) |^ k)
by A1, XREAL_1:102;
then
1 + (1 / (k !)) >= 1 + ((2 * (k ^2)) / ((2 * k) |^ k))
by XREAL_1:6;
then
(k !) * (1 + (1 / (k !))) >= (k !) * (1 + ((2 * (k ^2)) / ((2 * k) |^ k)))
by XREAL_1:66;
then A76:
((n + 1) |^ k) / (n choose k) < (k !) + 1
by A72, A70, A69, XXREAL_0:2;
Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)) >= (((1,p) In_Power n) . (k + 1)) + 0
by A38, XREAL_1:7;
then A77:
(((n + 1) |^ k) * (p |^ k)) / ((n choose k) * (p |^ k)) >= (((n + 1) |^ k) * (p |^ k)) / (Sum (((1,p) In_Power n) | (k + 1)))
by A39, A71, A1, XREAL_1:118;
((n + 1) |^ k) / (n choose k) = (((n + 1) |^ k) * (p |^ k)) / ((n choose k) * (p |^ k))
by XCMPLX_1:91, A1;
hence
(((n + 1) |^ k) * (p |^ k)) / (((p + 1) |^ n) mod (p |^ (k + 1))) < (k !) + 1
by A36, A76, A77, XXREAL_0:2; verum