let X, Y be Subset of S; ( ex r9 being POINT of S st
( between r,A,r9 & X = ((half-plane (A,r)) \/ A) \/ (half-plane (A,r9)) ) & ex r9 being POINT of S st
( between r,A,r9 & Y = ((half-plane (A,r)) \/ A) \/ (half-plane (A,r9)) ) implies X = Y )
assume that
A4:
ex r9 being POINT of S st
( between r,A,r9 & X = ((half-plane (A,r)) \/ A) \/ (half-plane (A,r9)) )
and
A5:
ex r9 being POINT of S st
( between r,A,r9 & Y = ((half-plane (A,r)) \/ A) \/ (half-plane (A,r9)) )
; X = Y
consider r9 being POINT of S such that
A6:
between r,A,r9
and
A7:
X = ((half-plane (A,r)) \/ A) \/ (half-plane (A,r9))
by A4;
consider r99 being POINT of S such that
A8:
between r,A,r99
and
A9:
Y = ((half-plane (A,r)) \/ A) \/ (half-plane (A,r99))
by A5;
( between r9,A,r & between r99,A,r )
by A8, A6, GTARSKI3:14;
then
A out r99,r9
;
then
r99 in half-plane (A,r9)
;
hence
X = Y
by A7, A9, A6, A8, Th23; verum