let S be satisfying_Tarski-model TarskiGeometryStruct ; for a, b, c, a1, b1, c1 being Element of S st b out a,c & b1 out a1,c1 & b,a equiv b1,a1 & b,c equiv b1,c1 holds
a,c equiv a1,c1
let a, b, c, a1, b1, c1 be Element of S; ( b out a,c & b1 out a1,c1 & b,a equiv b1,a1 & b,c equiv b1,c1 implies a,c equiv a1,c1 )
assume that
A1:
b out a,c
and
A2:
b1 out a1,c1
and
A3:
b,a equiv b1,a1
and
A4:
b,c equiv b1,c1
and
A5:
not a,c equiv a1,c1
; contradiction
now ( b out c,a & b1 out c1,a1 & not c,a equiv c1,a1 & a,b equiv a1,b1 & c,b equiv c1,b1 & ( not between c,a,b or not between c1,a1,b1 ) & ( not between a,c,b or not between a1,c1,b1 ) & ( b,a <= b,c or b1,c1 <= b1,a1 ) & ( b,c <= b,a or b1,a1 <= b1,c1 ) )thus
b out c,
a
by A1;
( b1 out c1,a1 & not c,a equiv c1,a1 & a,b equiv a1,b1 & c,b equiv c1,b1 & ( not between c,a,b or not between c1,a1,b1 ) & ( not between a,c,b or not between a1,c1,b1 ) & ( b,a <= b,c or b1,c1 <= b1,a1 ) & ( b,c <= b,a or b1,a1 <= b1,c1 ) )thus
b1 out c1,
a1
by A2;
( not c,a equiv c1,a1 & a,b equiv a1,b1 & c,b equiv c1,b1 & ( not between c,a,b or not between c1,a1,b1 ) & ( not between a,c,b or not between a1,c1,b1 ) & ( b,a <= b,c or b1,c1 <= b1,a1 ) & ( b,c <= b,a or b1,a1 <= b1,c1 ) )
(
b,
a equiv a1,
b1 &
b,
c equiv c1,
b1 & not
a,
c equiv c1,
a1 )
by Satz2p5, A3, A4, A5;
hence
( not
c,
a equiv c1,
a1 &
a,
b equiv a1,
b1 &
c,
b equiv c1,
b1 )
by Satz2p4;
( ( not between c,a,b or not between c1,a1,b1 ) & ( not between a,c,b or not between a1,c1,b1 ) & ( b,a <= b,c or b1,c1 <= b1,a1 ) & ( b,c <= b,a or b1,a1 <= b1,c1 ) )hence
( ( not
between c,
a,
b or not
between c1,
a1,
b1 ) & ( not
between a,
c,
b or not
between a1,
c1,
b1 ) )
by Satz4p3, A5;
( ( b,a <= b,c or b1,c1 <= b1,a1 ) & ( b,c <= b,a or b1,a1 <= b1,c1 ) )thus
( (
b,
a <= b,
c or
b1,
c1 <= b1,
a1 ) & (
b,
c <= b,
a or
b1,
a1 <= b1,
c1 ) )
by A3, Satz6p28Lem02, A4;
verum end;
hence
contradiction
by Satz6p28Lem01, A1, A2, Satz3p2; verum