set E = the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G);
set f = { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) } ;
A1:
now for x, y1, y2 being object st [x,y1] in { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) } & [x,y2] in { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) } holds
y1 = y2let x,
y1,
y2 be
object ;
( [x,y1] in { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) } & [x,y2] in { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) } implies y1 = y2 )assume
[x,y1] in { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) }
;
( [x,y2] in { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) } implies y1 = y2 )then consider P19,
P29 being
Element of
the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
such that A2:
[x,y1] = [P19,P29]
and A3:
ex
H1,
H2 being
strict Subgroup of
G ex
g being
Element of
G st
(
P19 = H1 &
P29 = H2 &
h " = g &
H2 = H1 |^ g )
;
A4:
x = P19
by A2, XTUPLE_0:1;
assume
[x,y2] in { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) }
;
y1 = y2then consider P199,
P299 being
Element of
the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
such that A5:
[x,y2] = [P199,P299]
and A6:
ex
H1,
H2 being
strict Subgroup of
G ex
g being
Element of
G st
(
P199 = H1 &
P299 = H2 &
h " = g &
H2 = H1 |^ g )
;
x = P199
by A5, XTUPLE_0:1;
hence
y1 = y2
by A2, A3, A5, A6, A4, XTUPLE_0:1;
verum end;
now for x being object st x in { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) } holds
ex y, z being object st x = [y,z]let x be
object ;
( x in { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) } implies ex y, z being object st x = [y,z] )assume
x in { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) }
;
ex y, z being object st x = [y,z]then consider P1,
P2 being
Element of
the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
such that A7:
x = [P1,P2]
and
ex
H1,
H2 being
strict Subgroup of
G ex
g being
Element of
G st
(
P1 = H1 &
P2 = H2 &
h " = g &
H2 = H1 |^ g )
;
reconsider y =
P1,
z =
P2 as
object ;
take y =
y;
ex z being object st x = [y,z]take z =
z;
x = [y,z]thus
x = [y,z]
by A7;
verum end;
then reconsider f = { [P1,P2] where P1, P2 is Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) : ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g ) } as Function by A1, FUNCT_1:def 1, RELAT_1:def 1;
now for y being object st y in rng f holds
y in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G)let y be
object ;
( y in rng f implies y in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) )assume
y in rng f
;
y in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G)then consider x being
object such that A8:
[x,y] in f
by XTUPLE_0:def 13;
consider P1,
P2 being
Element of
the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
such that A9:
[x,y] = [P1,P2]
and
ex
H1,
H2 being
strict Subgroup of
G ex
g being
Element of
G st
(
P1 = H1 &
P2 = H2 &
h " = g &
H2 = H1 |^ g )
by A8;
y = P2
by A9, XTUPLE_0:1;
hence
y in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
;
verum end;
then A10:
rng f c= the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G)
;
now for x being object holds
( ( x in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) implies ex y being object st [x,y] in f ) & ( ex y being object st [x,y] in f implies x in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) ) )let x be
object ;
( ( x in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) implies ex y being object st [x,y] in f ) & ( ex y being object st [x,y] in f implies x in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) ) )hereby ( ex y being object st [x,y] in f implies x in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) )
reconsider g =
h " as
Element of
G by GROUP_2:42;
assume
x in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
;
ex y being object st [x,y] in fthen reconsider P1 =
x as
Element of
the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G) ;
P1 in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
;
then consider H1 being
Element of
Subgroups G such that A11:
P1 = H1
and A12:
ex
P being
strict Subgroup of
G st
(
P = H1 &
P is_Sylow_p-subgroup_of_prime p )
;
reconsider H1 =
H1 as
strict Subgroup of
G by A12;
H1 is
p -group
by A12;
then consider H9 being
finite Group such that A13:
(
H1 = H9 &
H9 is
p -group )
;
set H2 =
H1 |^ g;
reconsider H2 =
H1 |^ g as
strict Subgroup of
G ;
reconsider H99 =
H2 as
finite Group ;
( ex
r being
Nat st
card H9 = p |^ r &
card H9 = card H99 )
by A13, GROUP_3:66;
then A14:
H99 is
p -group
;
reconsider H29 =
H2 as
Element of
Subgroups G by GROUP_3:def 1;
A15:
card H1 = card H2
by GROUP_3:66;
A16:
(card H1) * (index H1) =
card G
by GROUP_2:147
.=
(card H1) * (index H2)
by A15, GROUP_2:147
;
not
p divides index H1
by A12;
then
not
p divides index H2
by A16, XCMPLX_1:5;
then
H2 is_Sylow_p-subgroup_of_prime p
by A14;
then
H29 in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
;
then reconsider P2 =
H2 as
Element of
the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G) ;
reconsider y =
P2 as
object ;
take y =
y;
[x,y] in fthus
[x,y] in f
by A11;
verum
end; given y being
object such that A17:
[x,y] in f
;
x in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G)consider P1,
P2 being
Element of
the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
such that A18:
[x,y] = [P1,P2]
and
ex
H1,
H2 being
strict Subgroup of
G ex
g being
Element of
G st
(
P1 = H1 &
P2 = H2 &
h " = g &
H2 = H1 |^ g )
by A17;
x = P1
by A18, XTUPLE_0:1;
hence
x in the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
;
verum end;
then A19:
dom f = the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G)
by XTUPLE_0:def 12;
then reconsider f = f as Function of (the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G)),(the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G)) by A10, FUNCT_2:2;
take
f
; for P1 being Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) ex P2 being Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P2 = f . P1 & P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g )
thus
for P1 being Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) ex P2 being Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P2 = f . P1 & P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g )
verumproof
let P1 be
Element of
the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G);
ex P2 being Element of the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (p,G) ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P2 = f . P1 & P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g )
set P2 =
f . P1;
[P1,(f . P1)] in f
by A19, FUNCT_1:1;
then consider P19,
P29 being
Element of
the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G)
such that A20:
[P1,(f . P1)] = [P19,P29]
and A21:
ex
H1,
H2 being
strict Subgroup of
G ex
g being
Element of
G st
(
P19 = H1 &
P29 = H2 &
h " = g &
H2 = H1 |^ g )
;
reconsider P2 =
f . P1 as
Element of
the_sylow_p-subgroups_of_prime (
p,
G) ;
consider H1,
H2 being
strict Subgroup of
G,
g being
Element of
G such that A22:
(
P19 = H1 &
P29 = H2 &
h " = g )
and
H2 = H1 |^ g
by A21;
take
P2
;
ex H1, H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P2 = f . P1 & P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g )
take
H1
;
ex H2 being strict Subgroup of G ex g being Element of G st
( P2 = f . P1 & P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g )
take
H2
;
ex g being Element of G st
( P2 = f . P1 & P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g )
take
g
;
( P2 = f . P1 & P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g )
thus
P2 = f . P1
;
( P1 = H1 & P2 = H2 & h " = g & H2 = H1 |^ g )
thus
(
P1 = H1 &
P2 = H2 &
h " = g &
H2 = H1 |^ g )
by A20, A21, A22, XTUPLE_0:1;
verum
end;