let f, g be Function; ( f is one-to-one & g is one-to-one implies (g * f) " = (f ") * (g ") )
assume that
A1:
f is one-to-one
and
A2:
g is one-to-one
; (g * f) " = (f ") * (g ")
for y being object holds
( y in rng (g * f) iff y in dom ((f ") * (g ")) )
proof
let y be
object ;
( y in rng (g * f) iff y in dom ((f ") * (g ")) )
thus
(
y in rng (g * f) implies
y in dom ((f ") * (g ")) )
( y in dom ((f ") * (g ")) implies y in rng (g * f) )proof
assume
y in rng (g * f)
;
y in dom ((f ") * (g "))
then consider x being
object such that A3:
x in dom (g * f)
and A4:
y = (g * f) . x
by Def3;
A5:
f . x in dom g
by A3, Th11;
A6:
y = g . (f . x)
by A3, A4, Th12;
then
y in rng g
by A5, Def3;
then A7:
y in dom (g ")
by A2, Th31;
A8:
x in dom f
by A3, Th11;
(g ") . (g . (f . x)) =
((g ") * g) . (f . x)
by A5, Th13
.=
(id (dom g)) . (f . x)
by A2, Th38
.=
f . x
by A5, Th17
;
then
(g ") . y in rng f
by A8, A6, Def3;
then
(g ") . y in dom (f ")
by A1, Th31;
hence
y in dom ((f ") * (g "))
by A7, Th11;
verum
end;
assume A9:
y in dom ((f ") * (g "))
;
y in rng (g * f)
then
y in dom (g ")
by Th11;
then
y in rng g
by A2, Th31;
then consider z being
object such that A10:
z in dom g
and A11:
y = g . z
by Def3;
(g ") . y in dom (f ")
by A9, Th11;
then
(g ") . (g . z) in rng f
by A1, A11, Th31;
then
((g ") * g) . z in rng f
by A10, Th13;
then
(id (dom g)) . z in rng f
by A2, Th38;
then
z in rng f
by A10, Th17;
then consider x being
object such that A12:
(
x in dom f &
z = f . x )
by Def3;
(
x in dom (g * f) &
y = (g * f) . x )
by A10, A11, A12, Th11, Th13;
hence
y in rng (g * f)
by Def3;
verum
end;
then A13:
rng (g * f) = dom ((f ") * (g "))
by TARSKI:2;
for x being object holds
( x in dom (((f ") * (g ")) * (g * f)) iff x in dom (g * f) )
then A15:
dom (((f ") * (g ")) * (g * f)) = dom (g * f)
by TARSKI:2;
for x being object st x in dom (g * f) holds
(((f ") * (g ")) * (g * f)) . x = x
proof
let x be
object ;
( x in dom (g * f) implies (((f ") * (g ")) * (g * f)) . x = x )
assume A16:
x in dom (g * f)
;
(((f ") * (g ")) * (g * f)) . x = x
then A17:
f . x in dom g
by Th11;
(g * f) . x in rng (g * f)
by A16, Def3;
then A18:
g . (f . x) in dom ((f ") * (g "))
by A13, A16, Th12;
A19:
x in dom f
by A16, Th11;
thus (((f ") * (g ")) * (g * f)) . x =
((f ") * (g ")) . ((g * f) . x)
by A15, A16, Th12
.=
((f ") * (g ")) . (g . (f . x))
by A16, Th12
.=
(f ") . ((g ") . (g . (f . x)))
by A18, Th12
.=
(f ") . (((g ") * g) . (f . x))
by A17, Th13
.=
(f ") . ((id (dom g)) . (f . x))
by A2, Th38
.=
(f ") . (f . x)
by A17, Th17
.=
x
by A1, A19, Th33
;
verum
end;
then
((f ") * (g ")) * (g * f) = id (dom (g * f))
by A15, Th17;
hence
(g * f) " = (f ") * (g ")
by A1, A2, A13, Th40; verum