let M be Aleph; ( M is measurable implies M is strong_limit )
assume
M is measurable
; M is strong_limit
then consider F being Filter of M such that
A1:
F is_complete_with M
and
A2:
( not F is principal & F is being_ultrafilter )
;
assume
not M is strong_limit
; contradiction
then consider N being Cardinal such that
A3:
N in M
and
A4:
not exp (2,N) in M
;
A5:
M c= exp (2,N)
by A4, CARD_1:4;
then
M c= card (Funcs (N,2))
by CARD_2:def 3;
then consider Y being set such that
A6:
Y c= Funcs (N,2)
and
A7:
card Y = M
by Th36;
N is infinite
then reconsider N1 = N as Aleph ;
Y,M are_equipotent
by A7, CARD_1:def 2;
then consider f being Function such that
A9:
f is one-to-one
and
A10:
dom f = M
and
A11:
rng f = Y
by WELLORD2:def 4;
defpred S1[ set , set ] means f " { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . $1 = $2 ) } in F;
A12:
for A being Element of N1 ex i being Element of {{},1} st S1[A,i]
proof
let A be
Element of
N1;
ex i being Element of {{},1} st S1[A,i]
set Y1 =
{ h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) } ;
reconsider Inv1 =
f " { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) } as
Subset of
M by A10, RELAT_1:132;
set Y0 =
{ h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) } ;
reconsider Inv0 =
f " { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) } as
Subset of
M by A10, RELAT_1:132;
A13:
for
g1 being
Function of
N1,
{{},1} holds
( not
g1 in Y or
g1 in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) } or
g1 in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) } )
proof
let g1 be
Function of
N1,
{{},1};
( not g1 in Y or g1 in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) } or g1 in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) } )
assume A14:
g1 in Y
;
( g1 in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) } or g1 in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) } )
end;
Y \ { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) } = { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) }
proof
thus
Y \ { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) } c= { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) }
XBOOLE_0:def 10 { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) } c= Y \ { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) } proof
let X be
object ;
TARSKI:def 3 ( not X in Y \ { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) } or X in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) } )
assume A15:
X in Y \ { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) }
;
X in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) }
X in Y
by A15;
then consider g1 being
Function such that A16:
g1 = X
and A17:
(
dom g1 = N1 &
rng g1 c= {{},1} )
by A6, CARD_1:50, FUNCT_2:def 2;
reconsider g2 =
g1 as
Function of
N1,
{{},1} by A17, FUNCT_2:def 1, RELSET_1:4;
not
X in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) }
by A15, XBOOLE_0:def 5;
then
g2 in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) }
by A13, A15, A16;
hence
X in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) }
by A16;
verum
end;
let X be
object ;
TARSKI:def 3 ( not X in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) } or X in Y \ { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) } )
assume
X in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = 1 ) }
;
X in Y \ { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) }
then consider h being
Function of
N1,
{{},1} such that A18:
(
X = h &
h in Y )
and A19:
h . A = 1
;
not
h in { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) }
hence
X in Y \ { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . A = {} ) }
by A18, XBOOLE_0:def 5;
verum
end;
then A20:
Inv1 =
(f " (rng f)) \ Inv0
by A11, FUNCT_1:69
.=
M \ Inv0
by A10, RELAT_1:134
;
end;
consider g being Function of N1,{{},1} such that
A23:
for A being Element of N1 holds S1[A,g . A]
from FUNCT_2:sch 3(A12);
deffunc H1( Element of N1) -> set = f " { h where h is Function of N1,{{},1} : ( h in Y & h . $1 = g . $1 ) } ;
reconsider f1 = f as Function of M,Y by A10, A11, FUNCT_2:1;
set MEET = meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } ;
A24:
( rng (f | (meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } )) = f .: (meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } ) & f | (meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } ) is one-to-one )
by A9, FUNCT_1:52, RELAT_1:115;
card { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } c= card N1
from TREES_2:sch 2();
then
card { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } c= N1
;
then A25:
card { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } in M
by A3, ORDINAL1:12;
set B = the Element of N1;
A26:
{ H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } c= F
H1( the Element of N1) in { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 }
;
then A27:
meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } in F
by A1, A25, A26;
A28:
Y is infinite
by A7;
A29:
for X being set st X in meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } holds
f . X = g
A34:
f .: (meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } ) c= {g}
meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } = (dom f) /\ (meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } )
by A10, A27, XBOOLE_1:28;
then
dom (f | (meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } )) = meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 }
by RELAT_1:61;
then A35:
card (meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } ) c= card {g}
by A34, A24, CARD_1:10;
reconsider MEET = meet { H1(A) where A is Element of N1 : A in N1 } as Subset of M by A27;
F is_complete_with card M
by A1;
then
F is uniform
by A2, Th23;
then
card MEET = card M
by A27;
hence
contradiction
by A35; verum