let Al be QC-alphabet ; for p being Element of CQC-WFF Al
for f being FinSequence of CQC-WFF Al st |- f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*> holds
|- f ^ <*p*>
let p be Element of CQC-WFF Al; for f being FinSequence of CQC-WFF Al st |- f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*> holds
|- f ^ <*p*>
let f be FinSequence of CQC-WFF Al; ( |- f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*> implies |- f ^ <*p*> )
assume A1:
|- f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>
; |- f ^ <*p*>
set f5 = f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>;
set f4 = ((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>;
set f2 = ((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>;
set f1 = ((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>;
set f3 = (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) ^ <*p*>;
A2:
Suc (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) = 'not' p
by Th5;
A3:
Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) = (f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>
by Th5;
then A4:
1 < len ((Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) ^ <*p*>)
by Th9;
Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) = f ^ (<*('not' ('not' p))*> ^ <*('not' p)*>)
by A3, FINSEQ_1:32;
then A5:
Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) = f ^ <*('not' ('not' p)),('not' p)*>
by FINSEQ_1:def 9;
(len f) + 2 = (len f) + (len <*('not' ('not' p)),('not' p)*>)
by FINSEQ_1:44;
then
(len f) + 2 = len (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>))
by A5, FINSEQ_1:22;
then A6:
(len f) + 2 in dom (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>))
by A3, Th10;
(Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) . ((len f) + 2) = 'not' p
by A5, Th14;
then A7:
|- ((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>
by A2, A6, Lm2, Th33;
A8:
1 < len (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>)
by Th9;
A9:
Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) = (f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>
by Th5;
then
Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) = f ^ (<*('not' ('not' p))*> ^ <*('not' p)*>)
by FINSEQ_1:32;
then A10:
Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) = f ^ <*('not' ('not' p)),('not' p)*>
by FINSEQ_1:def 9;
(len f) + 2 = (len f) + (len <*('not' ('not' p)),('not' p)*>)
by FINSEQ_1:44;
then
(len f) + 2 = len (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>))
by A10, FINSEQ_1:22;
then
( 1 <= (len f) + 1 & (len f) + 1 <= len (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>)) )
by NAT_1:11, XREAL_1:6;
then A11:
(len f) + 1 in dom (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>))
by FINSEQ_3:25;
0 + 1 <= len (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>)
by Th10;
then A12:
((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*> = (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>)) ^ <*(Suc (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>))*>
by Th3;
A13:
1 <= len (f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>)
by Th10;
A14:
Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>) = (f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>
by Th5;
then
Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>) = f ^ (<*('not' ('not' p))*> ^ <*p*>)
by FINSEQ_1:32;
then A15:
Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>) = f ^ <*('not' ('not' p)),p*>
by FINSEQ_1:def 9;
A16:
Ant ((Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) ^ <*p*>) = Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)
by Th5;
then
Suc (Ant ((Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) ^ <*p*>)) = 'not' p
by A3, Th5;
then A17:
Suc (Ant ((Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) ^ <*p*>)) = 'not' (Suc (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>)))
by A14, Th5;
(len f) + 2 = (len f) + (len <*('not' ('not' p)),p*>)
by FINSEQ_1:44;
then
(len f) + 2 = len (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>))
by A15, FINSEQ_1:22;
then A18:
(len f) + 2 in dom (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>))
by A14, Th10;
A19:
Suc (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) = 'not' ('not' p)
by Th5;
then A20:
'not' (Suc (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) = Suc (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>)
by Th5;
(Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>)) . ((len f) + 1) = 'not' ('not' p)
by A10, Th14;
then A21:
|- ((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>
by A11, A19, Lm2, Th33;
A22:
Suc (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>) = p
by Th5;
then A23:
Suc ((Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) ^ <*p*>) = Suc (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>)
by Th5;
(Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>)) . ((len f) + 2) = p
by A15, Th14;
then A24:
|- ((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>
by A18, A22, Lm2, Th33;
Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) = Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>)
by A9, Th5;
then A25:
|- (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) ^ <*p*>
by A7, A21, A12, A20, Th44;
A26:
Ant (Ant ((Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) ^ <*p*>)) = f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>
by A3, A16, Th5;
then
Ant (Ant ((Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>) ^ <*('not' p)*>)) ^ <*p*>)) = Ant (Ant (((f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>) ^ <*p*>))
by A14, Th5;
then
|- (f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>) ^ <*p*>
by A25, A22, A24, A23, A26, A17, A4, A8, Th37;
then
|- (Ant (f ^ <*('not' ('not' p))*>)) ^ <*p*>
by A1, A13, Th45;
hence
|- f ^ <*p*>
by Th5; verum