let R be non empty connected Poset; ( R is well_founded implies FinPoset R is well_founded )
assume A1:
R is well_founded
; FinPoset R is well_founded
set IR = the InternalRel of R;
set CR = the carrier of R;
set FIR = FinOrd R;
set FCR = Fin the carrier of R;
assume
not FinPoset R is well_founded
; contradiction
then consider A being sequence of (FinPoset R) such that
A2:
A is descending
by WELLFND1:14;
set zz = { z where z is sequence of (FinPoset R) : z is descending } ;
A in { z where z is sequence of (FinPoset R) : z is descending }
by A2;
then reconsider zz = { z where z is sequence of (FinPoset R) : z is descending } as non empty set ;
set Z = [: the carrier of R,zz:];
defpred S1[ Nat, set , set ] means ex Sn2 being sequence of (FinPoset R) ex Smax being sequence of the carrier of R ex an being Element of R ex ix being Nat ex bnt, bn being sequence of (FinPoset R) st
( Sn2 = $2 `2 & ( for i being Nat ex Sn2i being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( Sn2i = Sn2 . i & Sn2i <> {} & Smax . i = PosetMax Sn2i ) ) & an = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) & ix = Smax mindex an & bnt = Sn2 ^\ ix & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = (bnt . i) \ {an} ) & ( for i being Nat st ix <= i holds
Smax . i = an ) & $3 = [an,bn] );
A3:
for n being Nat
for Sn being Element of [: the carrier of R,zz:] ex Sn1 being Element of [: the carrier of R,zz:] st S1[n,Sn,Sn1]
proof
let n be
Nat;
for Sn being Element of [: the carrier of R,zz:] ex Sn1 being Element of [: the carrier of R,zz:] st S1[n,Sn,Sn1]let Sn be
Element of
[: the carrier of R,zz:];
ex Sn1 being Element of [: the carrier of R,zz:] st S1[n,Sn,Sn1]
set Sn2 =
Sn `2 ;
Sn `2 in zz
;
then A4:
ex
z being
sequence of
(FinPoset R) st
(
z = Sn `2 &
z is
descending )
;
then reconsider Sn2 =
Sn `2 as
sequence of
(FinPoset R) ;
A5:
now for i being Nat holds not Sn2 . i = {} end;
defpred S2[
Nat,
set ]
means ex
Sn2i being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
Sn2i = Sn2 . $1 &
Sn2i <> {} & $2
= PosetMax Sn2i );
A8:
for
i being
Element of
NAT ex
y being
Element of the
carrier of
R st
S2[
i,
y]
consider Smax being
sequence of the
carrier of
R such that A9:
for
i being
Element of
NAT holds
S2[
i,
Smax . i]
from FUNCT_2:sch 3(A8);
set an =
MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R);
set ix =
Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R));
set bnt =
Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)));
defpred S3[
set ,
set ]
means ex
bni being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
bni = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . $1) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} & $2
= bni );
now for i being Nat ex y, bni being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( bni = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} & y = bni )let i be
Nat;
ex y, bni being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( bni = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} & y = bni )set bni =
((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))};
reconsider k =
(Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i as
finite Subset of the
carrier of
R by FINSUB_1:def 5;
k \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} in Fin the
carrier of
R
by FINSUB_1:def 5;
then reconsider bni =
((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} as
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R ;
set y =
bni;
take y =
bni;
ex bni being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( bni = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} & y = bni )take bni =
bni;
( bni = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} & y = bni )thus
bni = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))}
;
y = bnithus
y = bni
;
verum end;
then A10:
for
i being
Element of
NAT ex
y being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
S3[
i,
y]
;
defpred S4[
Nat]
means Smax . ((Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) + $1) = MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R);
A11:
dom Smax = NAT
by FUNCT_2:def 1;
A12:
rng Smax c= the
carrier of
R
by RELAT_1:def 19;
then A13:
MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R)
in rng Smax
by A1, Def17;
A14:
MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R)
is_minimal_wrt rng Smax, the
InternalRel of
R
by A1, A12, Def17;
A15:
S4[
0 ]
by A11, A13, DICKSON:def 11;
A16:
now for k being Nat st S4[k] holds
S4[k + 1]let k be
Nat;
( S4[k] implies S4[b1 + 1] )assume A17:
S4[
k]
;
S4[b1 + 1]reconsider ixk =
(Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) + k as
Element of
NAT by ORDINAL1:def 12;
set ixk1 =
(Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) + (k + 1);
set ixk19 =
((Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) + k) + 1;
consider Sn2ixk being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R such that A18:
Sn2ixk = Sn2 . ixk
and
Sn2ixk <> {}
and A19:
Smax . ixk = PosetMax Sn2ixk
by A9;
consider Sn2ixk1 being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R such that A20:
Sn2ixk1 = Sn2 . ((Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) + (k + 1))
and A21:
Sn2ixk1 <> {}
and A22:
Smax . ((Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) + (k + 1)) = PosetMax Sn2ixk1
by A9;
reconsider Sn2ixk9 =
Sn2ixk,
Sn2ixk19 =
Sn2ixk1 as
Element of
(FinPoset R) ;
(Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) + (k + 1) = ((Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) + k) + 1
;
then
[Sn2ixk19,Sn2ixk9] in FinOrd R
by A4, A18, A20;
then consider x,
y being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R such that A23:
Sn2ixk1 = x
and A24:
Sn2ixk = y
and A25:
(
x = {} or (
x <> {} &
y <> {} &
PosetMax x <> PosetMax y &
[(PosetMax x),(PosetMax y)] in the
InternalRel of
R ) or (
x <> {} &
y <> {} &
PosetMax x = PosetMax y &
[(x \ {(PosetMax x)}),(y \ {(PosetMax y)})] in FinOrd R ) )
by Th36;
end;
A27:
for
k being
Nat holds
S4[
k]
from NAT_1:sch 2(A15, A16);
A34:
now for i being Nat ex bnti being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( bnti = (Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i & PosetMax bnti = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) )let i be
Nat;
ex bnti being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( bnti = (Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i & PosetMax bnti = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) )set bnti =
(Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i;
reconsider bnti =
(Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i as
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R ;
take bnti =
bnti;
( bnti = (Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i & PosetMax bnti = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) )thus
bnti = (Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i
;
PosetMax bnti = MinElement ((rng Smax),R)set iix =
i + (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)));
ex
Sn2iix being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
Sn2iix = Sn2 . (i + (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) &
PosetMax Sn2iix = MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R) )
by A30, NAT_1:11;
hence
PosetMax bnti = MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R)
by NAT_1:def 3;
verum end;
consider bn being
sequence of
(Fin the carrier of R) such that A35:
for
i being
Element of
NAT holds
S3[
i,
bn . i]
from FUNCT_2:sch 3(A10);
reconsider bn =
bn as
sequence of
(FinPoset R) ;
set Sn1 =
[(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn];
A36:
Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) is
descending
by A4, Th37;
now for i being Nat holds
( bn . (i + 1) <> bn . i & [(bn . (i + 1)),(bn . i)] in FinOrd R )let i be
Nat;
( bn . (i + 1) <> bn . i & [(bn . (b1 + 1)),(bn . b1)] in FinOrd R )reconsider i0 =
i as
Element of
NAT by ORDINAL1:def 12;
A37:
ex
bni being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
bni = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i0) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} &
bn . i0 = bni )
by A35;
A38:
ex
bni1 being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
bni1 = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . (i + 1)) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} &
bn . (i + 1) = bni1 )
by A35;
reconsider bnti =
(Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i,
bnti1 =
(Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . (i + 1) as
Element of
(FinPoset R) ;
reconsider bnti9 =
bnti,
bnti19 =
bnti1 as
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R ;
A39:
bnti1 <> bnti
by A36;
[bnti1,bnti] in FinOrd R
by A36;
then consider x,
y being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R such that A40:
bnti1 = x
and A41:
bnti = y
and A42:
(
x = {} or (
x <> {} &
y <> {} &
PosetMax x <> PosetMax y &
[(PosetMax x),(PosetMax y)] in the
InternalRel of
R ) or (
x <> {} &
y <> {} &
PosetMax x = PosetMax y &
[(x \ {(PosetMax x)}),(y \ {(PosetMax y)})] in FinOrd R ) )
by Th36;
A46:
bnti9 <> {}
by A43;
A47:
bnti19 <> {}
by A43;
A48:
MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R)
in bnti
by A44, A46, Def13;
MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R)
in bnti1
by A44, A47, Def13;
hence
bn . (i + 1) <> bn . i
by A37, A38, A39, A48, Th1;
[(bn . (b1 + 1)),(bn . b1)] in FinOrd R end;
then
bn is
descending
;
then
bn in zz
;
then reconsider Sn1 =
[(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] as
Element of
[: the carrier of R,zz:] by ZFMISC_1:def 2;
take
Sn1
;
S1[n,Sn,Sn1]
take
Sn2
;
ex Smax being sequence of the carrier of R ex an being Element of R ex ix being Nat ex bnt, bn being sequence of (FinPoset R) st
( Sn2 = Sn `2 & ( for i being Nat ex Sn2i being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( Sn2i = Sn2 . i & Sn2i <> {} & Smax . i = PosetMax Sn2i ) ) & an = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) & ix = Smax mindex an & bnt = Sn2 ^\ ix & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = (bnt . i) \ {an} ) & ( for i being Nat st ix <= i holds
Smax . i = an ) & Sn1 = [an,bn] )
take
Smax
;
ex an being Element of R ex ix being Nat ex bnt, bn being sequence of (FinPoset R) st
( Sn2 = Sn `2 & ( for i being Nat ex Sn2i being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( Sn2i = Sn2 . i & Sn2i <> {} & Smax . i = PosetMax Sn2i ) ) & an = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) & ix = Smax mindex an & bnt = Sn2 ^\ ix & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = (bnt . i) \ {an} ) & ( for i being Nat st ix <= i holds
Smax . i = an ) & Sn1 = [an,bn] )
take
MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R)
;
ex ix being Nat ex bnt, bn being sequence of (FinPoset R) st
( Sn2 = Sn `2 & ( for i being Nat ex Sn2i being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( Sn2i = Sn2 . i & Sn2i <> {} & Smax . i = PosetMax Sn2i ) ) & MinElement ((rng Smax),R) = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) & ix = Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) & bnt = Sn2 ^\ ix & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = (bnt . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} ) & ( for i being Nat st ix <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) ) & Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] )
take
Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))
;
ex bnt, bn being sequence of (FinPoset R) st
( Sn2 = Sn `2 & ( for i being Nat ex Sn2i being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( Sn2i = Sn2 . i & Sn2i <> {} & Smax . i = PosetMax Sn2i ) ) & MinElement ((rng Smax),R) = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) & Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) = Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) & bnt = Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = (bnt . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} ) & ( for i being Nat st Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) ) & Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] )
take
Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))
;
ex bn being sequence of (FinPoset R) st
( Sn2 = Sn `2 & ( for i being Nat ex Sn2i being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( Sn2i = Sn2 . i & Sn2i <> {} & Smax . i = PosetMax Sn2i ) ) & MinElement ((rng Smax),R) = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) & Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) = Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) & Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) = Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} ) & ( for i being Nat st Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) ) & Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] )
take
bn
;
( Sn2 = Sn `2 & ( for i being Nat ex Sn2i being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( Sn2i = Sn2 . i & Sn2i <> {} & Smax . i = PosetMax Sn2i ) ) & MinElement ((rng Smax),R) = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) & Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) = Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) & Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) = Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} ) & ( for i being Nat st Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) ) & Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] )
thus
Sn2 = Sn `2
;
( ( for i being Nat ex Sn2i being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( Sn2i = Sn2 . i & Sn2i <> {} & Smax . i = PosetMax Sn2i ) ) & MinElement ((rng Smax),R) = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) & Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) = Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) & Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) = Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} ) & ( for i being Nat st Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) ) & Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] )
thus
for
i being
Nat ex
Sn2i being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
Sn2i = Sn2 . i &
Sn2i <> {} &
Smax . i = PosetMax Sn2i )
( MinElement ((rng Smax),R) = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) & Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) = Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) & Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) = Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} ) & ( for i being Nat st Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) ) & Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] )
thus
MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R)
= MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R)
;
( Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) = Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) & Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) = Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} ) & ( for i being Nat st Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) ) & Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] )
thus
Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) = Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))
;
( Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) = Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) & ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} ) & ( for i being Nat st Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) ) & Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] )
thus
Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R))) = Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))
;
( ( for i being Nat holds bn . i = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))} ) & ( for i being Nat st Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) ) & Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] )
hence
for
i being
Nat holds
bn . i = ((Sn2 ^\ (Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)))) . i) \ {(MinElement ((rng Smax),R))}
;
( ( for i being Nat st Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement ((rng Smax),R) ) & Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn] )
thus
for
i being
Nat st
Smax mindex (MinElement ((rng Smax),R)) <= i holds
Smax . i = MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R)
by A28;
Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn]
thus
Sn1 = [(MinElement ((rng Smax),R)),bn]
;
verum
end;
set aStart = the Element of R;
set SS = [ the Element of R,A];
A in zz
by A2;
then reconsider SS = [ the Element of R,A] as Element of [: the carrier of R,zz:] by ZFMISC_1:def 2;
consider S01 being Element of [: the carrier of R,zz:], S02 being sequence of (FinPoset R), S0max being sequence of the carrier of R, a0 being Element of R, i0 being Nat, b0t, b0 being sequence of (FinPoset R) such that
S02 = SS `2
and
A49:
for i being Nat ex S02i being Element of Fin the carrier of R st
( S02i = S02 . i & S02i <> {} & S0max . i = PosetMax S02i )
and
a0 = MinElement ((rng S0max),R)
and
i0 = S0max mindex a0
and
A50:
b0t = S02 ^\ i0
and
A51:
for i being Nat holds b0 . i = (b0t . i) \ {a0}
and
A52:
for i being Nat st i0 <= i holds
S0max . i = a0
and
A53:
S01 = [a0,b0]
by A3;
consider S being sequence of [: the carrier of R,zz:] such that
A54:
S . 0 = S01
and
A55:
for n being Nat holds S1[n,S . n,S . (n + 1)]
from RECDEF_1:sch 2(A3);
A56:
for n being Nat holds S1[n,S . n,S . (n + 1)]
by A55;
deffunc H1( object ) -> object = (S . $1) `1 ;
consider a being sequence of the carrier of R such that
A58:
for x being object st x in NAT holds
a . x = H1(x)
from FUNCT_2:sch 2(A57);
reconsider a = a as sequence of R ;
defpred S2[ Nat] means for i being Nat ex b being sequence of (FinPoset R) st
( b = (S . $1) `2 & ( for x being set st x in b . i holds
( x <> (S . $1) `1 & [x,((S . $1) `1)] in the InternalRel of R ) ) );
A59:
S2[ 0 ]
proof
let i be
Nat;
ex b being sequence of (FinPoset R) st
( b = (S . 0) `2 & ( for x being set st x in b . i holds
( x <> (S . 0) `1 & [x,((S . 0) `1)] in the InternalRel of R ) ) )
set b =
(S . 0) `2 ;
(S . 0) `2 in zz
;
then
ex
z being
sequence of
(FinPoset R) st
(
z = (S . 0) `2 &
z is
descending )
;
then reconsider b =
(S . 0) `2 as
sequence of
(FinPoset R) ;
take
b
;
( b = (S . 0) `2 & ( for x being set st x in b . i holds
( x <> (S . 0) `1 & [x,((S . 0) `1)] in the InternalRel of R ) ) )
thus
b = (S . 0) `2
;
for x being set st x in b . i holds
( x <> (S . 0) `1 & [x,((S . 0) `1)] in the InternalRel of R )
let x be
set ;
( x in b . i implies ( x <> (S . 0) `1 & [x,((S . 0) `1)] in the InternalRel of R ) )
assume A60:
x in b . i
;
( x <> (S . 0) `1 & [x,((S . 0) `1)] in the InternalRel of R )
b0 =
[a0,b0] `2
.=
b
by A53, A54
;
then A61:
x in (b0t . i) \ {a0}
by A51, A60;
then A62:
x in b0t . i
;
not
x in {a0}
by A61, XBOOLE_0:def 5;
hence A63:
x <> (S . 0) `1
by A53, A54, TARSKI:def 1;
[x,((S . 0) `1)] in the InternalRel of R
b . i c= the
carrier of
R
by FINSUB_1:def 5;
then reconsider x9 =
x as
Element of
R by A60;
A64:
x in S02 . (i + i0)
by A50, A62, NAT_1:def 3;
consider S02ib being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R such that A65:
S02ib = S02 . (i + i0)
and A66:
S02ib <> {}
and A67:
S0max . (i + i0) = PosetMax S02ib
by A49;
PosetMax S02ib = a0
by A52, A67, NAT_1:11;
then
a0 is_maximal_wrt S02ib, the
InternalRel of
R
by A66, Def13;
then
not
[a0,x] in the
InternalRel of
R
by A63, A64, A65, A53, A54, WAYBEL_4:def 23;
then
not
a0 <= x9
by ORDERS_2:def 5;
then
x9 <= a0
by WAYBEL_0:def 29;
hence
[x,((S . 0) `1)] in the
InternalRel of
R
by A53, A54, ORDERS_2:def 5;
verum
end;
A68:
for n being Nat st S2[n] holds
S2[n + 1]
proof
let n be
Nat;
( S2[n] implies S2[n + 1] )
assume
S2[
n]
;
S2[n + 1]
let i be
Nat;
ex b being sequence of (FinPoset R) st
( b = (S . (n + 1)) `2 & ( for x being set st x in b . i holds
( x <> (S . (n + 1)) `1 & [x,((S . (n + 1)) `1)] in the InternalRel of R ) ) )
set n1 =
n + 1;
reconsider n1 =
n + 1 as
Nat ;
set b =
(S . n1) `2 ;
consider Sn2 being
sequence of
(FinPoset R),
Smax being
sequence of the
carrier of
R,
an being
Element of
R,
ix being
Nat,
bnt,
bn being
sequence of
(FinPoset R) such that
Sn2 = (S . n) `2
and A69:
for
i being
Nat ex
Sn2i being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
Sn2i = Sn2 . i &
Sn2i <> {} &
Smax . i = PosetMax Sn2i )
and
an = MinElement (
(rng Smax),
R)
and
ix = Smax mindex an
and A70:
bnt = Sn2 ^\ ix
and A71:
for
i being
Nat holds
bn . i = (bnt . i) \ {an}
and A72:
for
i being
Nat st
ix <= i holds
Smax . i = an
and A73:
S . (n + 1) = [an,bn]
by A56;
(S . n1) `2 in zz
;
then
ex
z being
sequence of
(FinPoset R) st
(
z = (S . n1) `2 &
z is
descending )
;
then reconsider b =
(S . n1) `2 as
sequence of
(FinPoset R) ;
take
b
;
( b = (S . (n + 1)) `2 & ( for x being set st x in b . i holds
( x <> (S . (n + 1)) `1 & [x,((S . (n + 1)) `1)] in the InternalRel of R ) ) )
thus
b = (S . (n + 1)) `2
;
for x being set st x in b . i holds
( x <> (S . (n + 1)) `1 & [x,((S . (n + 1)) `1)] in the InternalRel of R )
let x be
set ;
( x in b . i implies ( x <> (S . (n + 1)) `1 & [x,((S . (n + 1)) `1)] in the InternalRel of R ) )
assume A74:
x in b . i
;
( x <> (S . (n + 1)) `1 & [x,((S . (n + 1)) `1)] in the InternalRel of R )
bn =
[an,bn] `2
.=
b
by A73
;
then A75:
x in (bnt . i) \ {an}
by A71, A74;
then A76:
x in bnt . i
;
not
x in {an}
by A75, XBOOLE_0:def 5;
hence A77:
x <> (S . (n + 1)) `1
by A73, TARSKI:def 1;
[x,((S . (n + 1)) `1)] in the InternalRel of R
b . i c= the
carrier of
R
by FINSUB_1:def 5;
then reconsider x9 =
x as
Element of
R by A74;
A78:
x in Sn2 . (i + ix)
by A70, A76, NAT_1:def 3;
consider Sn2ib being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R such that A79:
Sn2ib = Sn2 . (i + ix)
and A80:
Sn2ib <> {}
and A81:
Smax . (i + ix) = PosetMax Sn2ib
by A69;
PosetMax Sn2ib = an
by A72, A81, NAT_1:11;
then
an is_maximal_wrt Sn2ib, the
InternalRel of
R
by A80, Def13;
then
not
[an,x] in the
InternalRel of
R
by A77, A78, A79, A73, WAYBEL_4:def 23;
then
not
an <= x9
by ORDERS_2:def 5;
then
x9 <= an
by WAYBEL_0:def 29;
hence
[x,((S . (n + 1)) `1)] in the
InternalRel of
R
by A73, ORDERS_2:def 5;
verum
end;
A82:
for n being Nat holds S2[n]
from NAT_1:sch 2(A59, A68);
defpred S3[ Nat] means ex b being sequence of (FinPoset R) ex i being Nat st
( b = (S . $1) `2 & a . ($1 + 1) in b . i );
A83:
S3[ 0 ]
proof
set b =
(S . 0) `2 ;
(S . 0) `2 in zz
;
then
ex
z being
sequence of
(FinPoset R) st
(
z = (S . 0) `2 &
z is
descending )
;
then reconsider b =
(S . 0) `2 as
sequence of
(FinPoset R) ;
take
b
;
ex i being Nat st
( b = (S . 0) `2 & a . (0 + 1) in b . i )
A84:
a . (0 + 1) = (S . (0 + 1)) `1
by A58;
consider S12 being
sequence of
(FinPoset R),
S1max being
sequence of the
carrier of
R,
a1 being
Element of
R,
i1 being
Nat,
b1t,
b1 being
sequence of
(FinPoset R) such that A85:
S12 = (S . 0) `2
and A86:
for
i being
Nat ex
S12i being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
S12i = S12 . i &
S12i <> {} &
S1max . i = PosetMax S12i )
and A87:
a1 = MinElement (
(rng S1max),
R)
and
i1 = S1max mindex a1
and
b1t = S12 ^\ i1
and
for
i being
Nat holds
b1 . i = (b1t . i) \ {a1}
and
for
i being
Nat st
i1 <= i holds
S1max . i = a1
and A88:
S . (0 + 1) = [a1,b1]
by A55;
rng S1max c= the
carrier of
R
by RELAT_1:def 19;
then
a1 in rng S1max
by A1, A87, Def17;
then consider i being
object such that A89:
i in dom S1max
and A90:
S1max . i = a1
by FUNCT_1:def 3;
A91:
ex
S12i being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
S12i = S12 . i &
S12i <> {} &
S1max . i = PosetMax S12i )
by A86, A89;
reconsider i =
i as
Nat by A89;
take
i
;
( b = (S . 0) `2 & a . (0 + 1) in b . i )
thus
b = (S . 0) `2
;
a . (0 + 1) in b . i
A92:
a1 in b . i
by A85, A90, A91, Def13;
thus
a . (0 + 1) in b . i
by A84, A88, A92;
verum
end;
A93:
for n being Nat st S3[n] holds
S3[n + 1]
proof
let n be
Nat;
( S3[n] implies S3[n + 1] )
assume
S3[
n]
;
S3[n + 1]
set b =
(S . (n + 1)) `2 ;
(S . (n + 1)) `2 in zz
;
then
ex
z being
sequence of
(FinPoset R) st
(
z = (S . (n + 1)) `2 &
z is
descending )
;
then reconsider b =
(S . (n + 1)) `2 as
sequence of
(FinPoset R) ;
take
b
;
ex i being Nat st
( b = (S . (n + 1)) `2 & a . ((n + 1) + 1) in b . i )
set n1 =
n + 1;
reconsider n1 =
n + 1 as
Nat ;
consider Sn12 being
sequence of
(FinPoset R),
Sn1max being
sequence of the
carrier of
R,
an1 being
Element of
R,
in1 being
Nat,
bn1t,
bn1 being
sequence of
(FinPoset R) such that A94:
Sn12 = (S . n1) `2
and A95:
for
i being
Nat ex
Sn12i being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
Sn12i = Sn12 . i &
Sn12i <> {} &
Sn1max . i = PosetMax Sn12i )
and A96:
an1 = MinElement (
(rng Sn1max),
R)
and
in1 = Sn1max mindex an1
and
bn1t = Sn12 ^\ in1
and
for
i being
Nat holds
bn1 . i = (bn1t . i) \ {an1}
and
for
i being
Nat st
in1 <= i holds
Sn1max . i = an1
and A97:
S . (n1 + 1) = [an1,bn1]
by A55;
rng Sn1max c= the
carrier of
R
by RELAT_1:def 19;
then
an1 in rng Sn1max
by A1, A96, Def17;
then consider i being
object such that A98:
i in dom Sn1max
and A99:
Sn1max . i = an1
by FUNCT_1:def 3;
A100:
ex
Sn12i being
Element of
Fin the
carrier of
R st
(
Sn12i = Sn12 . i &
Sn12i <> {} &
Sn1max . i = PosetMax Sn12i )
by A95, A98;
reconsider i =
i as
Nat by A98;
take
i
;
( b = (S . (n + 1)) `2 & a . ((n + 1) + 1) in b . i )
thus
b = (S . (n + 1)) `2
;
a . ((n + 1) + 1) in b . i
A101:
an1 in b . i
by A94, A99, A100, Def13;
[an1,bn1] `1 = an1
;
hence
a . ((n + 1) + 1) in b . i
by A58, A101, A97;
verum
end;
A102:
for n being Nat holds S3[n]
from NAT_1:sch 2(A83, A93);
defpred S4[ Nat] means ( a . ($1 + 1) <> a . $1 & [(a . ($1 + 1)),(a . $1)] in the InternalRel of R );
A103:
S4[ 0 ]
A107:
for n being Nat st S4[n] holds
S4[n + 1]
for n being Nat holds S4[n]
from NAT_1:sch 2(A103, A107);
then
a is descending
;
hence
contradiction
by A1, WELLFND1:14; verum