let X1, X2 be set ; ( ( for x being set holds
( x in X1 iff ex y being set st
( [x,y] in R & y in Y ) ) ) & ( for x being set holds
( x in X2 iff ex y being set st
( [x,y] in R & y in Y ) ) ) implies X1 = X2 )
assume that
A4:
for x being set holds
( x in X1 iff ex y being set st
( [x,y] in R & y in Y ) )
and
A5:
for x being set holds
( x in X2 iff ex y being set st
( [x,y] in R & y in Y ) )
; X1 = X2
now let x be
set ;
( x in X1 iff x in X2 )
(
x in X1 iff ex
y being
set st
(
[x,y] in R &
y in Y ) )
by A4;
hence
(
x in X1 iff
x in X2 )
by A5;
verum end;
hence
X1 = X2
by TARSKI:1; verum