thus
( G is associative implies the multF of G is associative )
( the multF of G is associative implies G is associative )proof
assume A3:
for
a,
b,
c being
Element of
G holds
(a * b) * c = a * (b * c)
;
GROUP_1:def 4 the multF of G is associative
let a be
Element of
G;
BINOP_1:def 14 for b1, b2 being Element of the carrier of G holds the multF of G . (a,( the multF of G . (b1,b2))) = the multF of G . (( the multF of G . (a,b1)),b2)let b,
c be
Element of
G;
the multF of G . (a,( the multF of G . (b,c))) = the multF of G . (( the multF of G . (a,b)),c)
(
H2(
G)
. (
(a * b),
c)
= (a * b) * c &
H2(
G)
. (
a,
(b * c))
= a * (b * c) )
;
hence
the
multF of
G . (
a,
( the multF of G . (b,c)))
= the
multF of
G . (
( the multF of G . (a,b)),
c)
by A3;
verum
end;
assume A4:
for a, b, c being Element of G holds H2(G) . (a,(H2(G) . (b,c))) = H2(G) . ((H2(G) . (a,b)),c)
; BINOP_1:def 14 G is associative
let a be Element of G; GROUP_1:def 4 for b1, b2 being Element of the carrier of G holds (a [*] b1) [*] b2 = a [*] (b1 [*] b2)
let b, c be Element of G; (a [*] b) [*] c = a [*] (b [*] c)
thus
(a [*] b) [*] c = a [*] (b [*] c)
by A4; verum