let C, D be non empty set ; for d being Element of D
for f, f9 being Function of C,D
for F being BinOp of D st F is associative holds
(F [:] (id D),d) * (F .: f,f9) = F .: f,((F [:] (id D),d) * f9)
let d be Element of D; for f, f9 being Function of C,D
for F being BinOp of D st F is associative holds
(F [:] (id D),d) * (F .: f,f9) = F .: f,((F [:] (id D),d) * f9)
let f, f9 be Function of C,D; for F being BinOp of D st F is associative holds
(F [:] (id D),d) * (F .: f,f9) = F .: f,((F [:] (id D),d) * f9)
let F be BinOp of D; ( F is associative implies (F [:] (id D),d) * (F .: f,f9) = F .: f,((F [:] (id D),d) * f9) )
assume A1:
F is associative
; (F [:] (id D),d) * (F .: f,f9) = F .: f,((F [:] (id D),d) * f9)
now let c be
Element of
C;
((F [:] (id D),d) * (F .: f,f9)) . c = (F .: f,((F [:] (id D),d) * f9)) . cthus ((F [:] (id D),d) * (F .: f,f9)) . c =
(F [:] (id D),d) . ((F .: f,f9) . c)
by FUNCT_2:21
.=
(F [:] (id D),d) . (F . (f . c),(f9 . c))
by FUNCOP_1:48
.=
F . ((id D) . (F . (f . c),(f9 . c))),
d
by FUNCOP_1:60
.=
F . (F . (f . c),(f9 . c)),
d
by FUNCT_1:35
.=
F . (f . c),
(F . (f9 . c),d)
by A1, BINOP_1:def 3
.=
F . (f . c),
((F [:] f9,d) . c)
by FUNCOP_1:60
.=
F . (f . c),
(((F [:] (id D),d) * f9) . c)
by FUNCOP_1:63
.=
(F .: f,((F [:] (id D),d) * f9)) . c
by FUNCOP_1:48
;
verum end;
hence
(F [:] (id D),d) * (F .: f,f9) = F .: f,((F [:] (id D),d) * f9)
by FUNCT_2:113; verum