let CPS be proper CollSp; for a, b, c being POINT of
for a', b', c' being Point of st a = a' & b = b' & c = c' holds
( a',b',c' is_collinear iff ex P being LINE of st
( a on P & b on P & c on P ) )
let a, b, c be POINT of ; for a', b', c' being Point of st a = a' & b = b' & c = c' holds
( a',b',c' is_collinear iff ex P being LINE of st
( a on P & b on P & c on P ) )
let a', b', c' be Point of ; ( a = a' & b = b' & c = c' implies ( a',b',c' is_collinear iff ex P being LINE of st
( a on P & b on P & c on P ) ) )
assume that
A1:
a = a'
and
A2:
b = b'
and
A3:
c = c'
; ( a',b',c' is_collinear iff ex P being LINE of st
( a on P & b on P & c on P ) )
hereby ( ex P being LINE of st
( a on P & b on P & c on P ) implies a',b',c' is_collinear )
assume A4:
a',
b',
c' is_collinear
;
ex P being LINE of st
( a on P & b on P & c on P )A5:
now set X =
Line a',
b';
assume
a' <> b'
;
ex P being LINE of st
( a on P & b on P & c on P )then reconsider P' =
Line a',
b' as
LINE of
CPS by COLLSP:def 7;
reconsider P =
P' as
LINE of
by Th2;
a' in Line a',
b'
by COLLSP:16;
then A6:
a on P
by A1, Th9;
b' in Line a',
b'
by COLLSP:16;
then A7:
b on P
by A2, Th9;
c' in Line a',
b'
by A4, COLLSP:17;
then
c on P
by A3, Th9;
hence
ex
P being
LINE of st
(
a on P &
b on P &
c on P )
by A6, A7;
verum end; hence
ex
P being
LINE of st
(
a on P &
b on P &
c on P )
by A5;
verum
end;
given P being LINE of such that A9:
( a on P & b on P )
and
A10:
c on P
; a',b',c' is_collinear
reconsider P' = P as LINE of CPS by Th2;
A11:
c' in P'
by A3, A10, Th9;
( a' in P' & b' in P' )
by A1, A2, A9, Th9;
hence
a',b',c' is_collinear
by A11, COLLSP:25; verum