let H be ZF-formula; :: thesis: for M being non empty set
for v, v' being Function of VAR ,M st ( for x being Variable st x in Free H holds
v' . x = v . x ) & M,v |= H holds
M,v' |= H
let M be non empty set ; :: thesis: for v, v' being Function of VAR ,M st ( for x being Variable st x in Free H holds
v' . x = v . x ) & M,v |= H holds
M,v' |= H
defpred S1[ ZF-formula] means for v, v' being Function of VAR ,M st ( for x being Variable st x in Free $1 holds
v' . x = v . x ) & M,v |= $1 holds
M,v' |= $1;
A1:
for x1, x2 being Variable holds
( S1[x1 '=' x2] & S1[x1 'in' x2] )
proof
let x1,
x2 be
Variable;
:: thesis: ( S1[x1 '=' x2] & S1[x1 'in' x2] )
A2:
(
Free (x1 '=' x2) = {x1,x2} &
Free (x1 'in' x2) = {x1,x2} )
by Th63, Th64;
thus
S1[
x1 '=' x2]
:: thesis: S1[x1 'in' x2]proof
let v,
v' be
Function of
VAR ,
M;
:: thesis: ( ( for x being Variable st x in Free (x1 '=' x2) holds
v' . x = v . x ) & M,v |= x1 '=' x2 implies M,v' |= x1 '=' x2 )
assume A3:
for
x being
Variable st
x in Free (x1 '=' x2) holds
v' . x = v . x
;
:: thesis: ( not M,v |= x1 '=' x2 or M,v' |= x1 '=' x2 )
assume
M,
v |= x1 '=' x2
;
:: thesis: M,v' |= x1 '=' x2
then A4:
v . x1 = v . x2
by ZF_MODEL:12;
(
x1 in Free (x1 '=' x2) &
x2 in Free (x1 '=' x2) )
by A2, TARSKI:def 2;
then
(
v' . x1 = v . x1 &
v' . x2 = v . x2 )
by A3;
hence
M,
v' |= x1 '=' x2
by A4, ZF_MODEL:12;
:: thesis: verum
end;
let v,
v' be
Function of
VAR ,
M;
:: thesis: ( ( for x being Variable st x in Free (x1 'in' x2) holds
v' . x = v . x ) & M,v |= x1 'in' x2 implies M,v' |= x1 'in' x2 )
assume A5:
for
x being
Variable st
x in Free (x1 'in' x2) holds
v' . x = v . x
;
:: thesis: ( not M,v |= x1 'in' x2 or M,v' |= x1 'in' x2 )
assume
M,
v |= x1 'in' x2
;
:: thesis: M,v' |= x1 'in' x2
then A6:
v . x1 in v . x2
by ZF_MODEL:13;
(
x1 in Free (x1 'in' x2) &
x2 in Free (x1 'in' x2) )
by A2, TARSKI:def 2;
then
(
v' . x1 = v . x1 &
v' . x2 = v . x2 )
by A5;
hence
M,
v' |= x1 'in' x2
by A6, ZF_MODEL:13;
:: thesis: verum
end;
A7:
for H being ZF-formula st S1[H] holds
S1[ 'not' H]
proof
let H be
ZF-formula;
:: thesis: ( S1[H] implies S1[ 'not' H] )
assume A8:
S1[
H]
;
:: thesis: S1[ 'not' H]
let v,
v' be
Function of
VAR ,
M;
:: thesis: ( ( for x being Variable st x in Free ('not' H) holds
v' . x = v . x ) & M,v |= 'not' H implies M,v' |= 'not' H )
assume A9:
for
x being
Variable st
x in Free ('not' H) holds
v' . x = v . x
;
:: thesis: ( not M,v |= 'not' H or M,v' |= 'not' H )
assume
M,
v |= 'not' H
;
:: thesis: M,v' |= 'not' H
then A10:
not
M,
v |= H
by ZF_MODEL:14;
then
not
M,
v' |= H
by A8, A10;
hence
M,
v' |= 'not' H
by ZF_MODEL:14;
:: thesis: verum
end;
A11:
for H1, H2 being ZF-formula st S1[H1] & S1[H2] holds
S1[H1 '&' H2]
proof
let H1,
H2 be
ZF-formula;
:: thesis: ( S1[H1] & S1[H2] implies S1[H1 '&' H2] )
assume A12:
(
S1[
H1] &
S1[
H2] )
;
:: thesis: S1[H1 '&' H2]
A13:
Free (H1 '&' H2) = (Free H1) \/ (Free H2)
by Th66;
let v,
v' be
Function of
VAR ,
M;
:: thesis: ( ( for x being Variable st x in Free (H1 '&' H2) holds
v' . x = v . x ) & M,v |= H1 '&' H2 implies M,v' |= H1 '&' H2 )
assume A14:
for
x being
Variable st
x in Free (H1 '&' H2) holds
v' . x = v . x
;
:: thesis: ( not M,v |= H1 '&' H2 or M,v' |= H1 '&' H2 )
assume
M,
v |= H1 '&' H2
;
:: thesis: M,v' |= H1 '&' H2
then A15:
(
M,
v |= H1 &
M,
v |= H2 )
by ZF_MODEL:15;
then A16:
M,
v' |= H1
by A12, A15;
then
M,
v' |= H2
by A12, A15;
hence
M,
v' |= H1 '&' H2
by A16, ZF_MODEL:15;
:: thesis: verum
end;
A17:
for H being ZF-formula
for x being Variable st S1[H] holds
S1[ All x,H]
proof
let H be
ZF-formula;
:: thesis: for x being Variable st S1[H] holds
S1[ All x,H]let x1 be
Variable;
:: thesis: ( S1[H] implies S1[ All x1,H] )
assume A18:
S1[
H]
;
:: thesis: S1[ All x1,H]
let v,
v' be
Function of
VAR ,
M;
:: thesis: ( ( for x being Variable st x in Free (All x1,H) holds
v' . x = v . x ) & M,v |= All x1,H implies M,v' |= All x1,H )
assume that A19:
for
x being
Variable st
x in Free (All x1,H) holds
v' . x = v . x
and A20:
M,
v |= All x1,
H
;
:: thesis: M,v' |= All x1,H
now let m be
Element of
M;
:: thesis: M,v' / x1,m |= HA21:
(
M,
v / x1,
m |= H &
Free (All x1,H) = (Free H) \ {x1} )
by A20, Th67, Th80;
now let x be
Variable;
:: thesis: ( x in Free H implies (v' / x1,m) . x = (v / x1,m) . x )assume
x in Free H
;
:: thesis: (v' / x1,m) . x = (v / x1,m) . xthen
( (
x in Free (All x1,H) & not
x in {x1} ) or
x in {x1} )
by A21, XBOOLE_0:def 5;
then
( (
v' . x = v . x &
x <> x1 ) or
x = x1 )
by A19, TARSKI:def 1;
then
( (
(v' / x1,m) . x = v . x &
v . x = (v / x1,m) . x ) or (
(v / x1,m) . x = m &
(v' / x1,m) . x = m ) )
by FUNCT_7:34, FUNCT_7:130;
hence
(v' / x1,m) . x = (v / x1,m) . x
;
:: thesis: verum end; hence
M,
v' / x1,
m |= H
by A18, A21;
:: thesis: verum end;
hence
M,
v' |= All x1,
H
by Th80;
:: thesis: verum
end;
for H being ZF-formula holds S1[H]
from ZF_LANG1:sch 1(A1, A7, A11, A17);
hence
for v, v' being Function of VAR ,M st ( for x being Variable st x in Free H holds
v' . x = v . x ) & M,v |= H holds
M,v' |= H
; :: thesis: verum