let F, H be Element of QC-WFF ; :: thesis: ( F is_subformula_of H iff F is_proper_subformula_of 'not' H )
H is_immediate_constituent_of 'not' H
by Th60;
hence
( F is_subformula_of H implies F is_proper_subformula_of 'not' H )
by Th83; :: thesis: ( F is_proper_subformula_of 'not' H implies F is_subformula_of H )
given n being Element of NAT , L being FinSequence such that A1:
( 1 <= n & len L = n & L . 1 = F & L . n = 'not' H )
and
A2:
for k being Element of NAT st 1 <= k & k < n holds
ex H1, F1 being Element of QC-WFF st
( L . k = H1 & L . (k + 1) = F1 & H1 is_immediate_constituent_of F1 )
; :: according to QC_LANG2:def 21,QC_LANG2:def 22 :: thesis: ( not F <> 'not' H or F is_subformula_of H )
assume
F <> 'not' H
; :: thesis: F is_subformula_of H
then
1 < n
by A1, XXREAL_0:1;
then
1 + 1 <= n
by NAT_1:13;
then consider k being Nat such that
A3:
n = 2 + k
by NAT_1:10;
reconsider k = k as Element of NAT by ORDINAL1:def 13;
reconsider L1 = L | (Seg (1 + k)) as FinSequence by FINSEQ_1:19;
take m = 1 + k; :: according to QC_LANG2:def 21 :: thesis: ex L being FinSequence st
( 1 <= m & len L = m & L . 1 = F & L . m = H & ( for k being Element of NAT st 1 <= k & k < m holds
ex G1, H1 being Element of QC-WFF st
( L . k = G1 & L . (k + 1) = H1 & G1 is_immediate_constituent_of H1 ) ) )
take
L1
; :: thesis: ( 1 <= m & len L1 = m & L1 . 1 = F & L1 . m = H & ( for k being Element of NAT st 1 <= k & k < m holds
ex G1, H1 being Element of QC-WFF st
( L1 . k = G1 & L1 . (k + 1) = H1 & G1 is_immediate_constituent_of H1 ) ) )
thus A4:
1 <= m
by NAT_1:11; :: thesis: ( len L1 = m & L1 . 1 = F & L1 . m = H & ( for k being Element of NAT st 1 <= k & k < m holds
ex G1, H1 being Element of QC-WFF st
( L1 . k = G1 & L1 . (k + 1) = H1 & G1 is_immediate_constituent_of H1 ) ) )
1 + k <= (1 + k) + 1
by NAT_1:11;
hence
len L1 = m
by A1, A3, FINSEQ_1:21; :: thesis: ( L1 . 1 = F & L1 . m = H & ( for k being Element of NAT st 1 <= k & k < m holds
ex G1, H1 being Element of QC-WFF st
( L1 . k = G1 & L1 . (k + 1) = H1 & G1 is_immediate_constituent_of H1 ) ) )
hence
L1 . 1 = F
by A1, A4; :: thesis: ( L1 . m = H & ( for k being Element of NAT st 1 <= k & k < m holds
ex G1, H1 being Element of QC-WFF st
( L1 . k = G1 & L1 . (k + 1) = H1 & G1 is_immediate_constituent_of H1 ) ) )
m < m + 1
by NAT_1:13;
then consider F1, G1 being Element of QC-WFF such that
A6:
( L . m = F1 & L . (m + 1) = G1 & F1 is_immediate_constituent_of G1 )
by A2, A3, A4;
F1 = H
by A1, A3, A6, Th60;
hence
L1 . m = H
by A4, A5, A6; :: thesis: for k being Element of NAT st 1 <= k & k < m holds
ex G1, H1 being Element of QC-WFF st
( L1 . k = G1 & L1 . (k + 1) = H1 & G1 is_immediate_constituent_of H1 )
let j be Element of NAT ; :: thesis: ( 1 <= j & j < m implies ex G1, H1 being Element of QC-WFF st
( L1 . j = G1 & L1 . (j + 1) = H1 & G1 is_immediate_constituent_of H1 ) )
assume A7:
( 1 <= j & j < m )
; :: thesis: ex G1, H1 being Element of QC-WFF st
( L1 . j = G1 & L1 . (j + 1) = H1 & G1 is_immediate_constituent_of H1 )
then A8:
( 1 <= 1 + j & 1 + j = j + 1 & j <= m & j + 1 <= m )
by NAT_1:13;
m <= m + 1
by NAT_1:11;
then
j < n
by A3, A7, XXREAL_0:2;
then consider F1, G1 being Element of QC-WFF such that
A9:
( L . j = F1 & L . (j + 1) = G1 & F1 is_immediate_constituent_of G1 )
by A2, A7;
take
F1
; :: thesis: ex H1 being Element of QC-WFF st
( L1 . j = F1 & L1 . (j + 1) = H1 & F1 is_immediate_constituent_of H1 )
take
G1
; :: thesis: ( L1 . j = F1 & L1 . (j + 1) = G1 & F1 is_immediate_constituent_of G1 )
thus
( L1 . j = F1 & L1 . (j + 1) = G1 & F1 is_immediate_constituent_of G1 )
by A5, A7, A8, A9; :: thesis: verum