let C, D be non empty set ; :: thesis: for d being Element of D
for f, f' being Function of C,D
for F being BinOp of D st F is associative holds
(F [;] d,(id D)) * (F .: f,f') = F .: ((F [;] d,(id D)) * f),f'
let d be Element of D; :: thesis: for f, f' being Function of C,D
for F being BinOp of D st F is associative holds
(F [;] d,(id D)) * (F .: f,f') = F .: ((F [;] d,(id D)) * f),f'
let f, f' be Function of C,D; :: thesis: for F being BinOp of D st F is associative holds
(F [;] d,(id D)) * (F .: f,f') = F .: ((F [;] d,(id D)) * f),f'
let F be BinOp of D; :: thesis: ( F is associative implies (F [;] d,(id D)) * (F .: f,f') = F .: ((F [;] d,(id D)) * f),f' )
assume A1:
F is associative
; :: thesis: (F [;] d,(id D)) * (F .: f,f') = F .: ((F [;] d,(id D)) * f),f'
now let c be
Element of
C;
:: thesis: ((F [;] d,(id D)) * (F .: f,f')) . c = (F .: ((F [;] d,(id D)) * f),f') . cthus ((F [;] d,(id D)) * (F .: f,f')) . c =
(F [;] d,(id D)) . ((F .: f,f') . c)
by FUNCT_2:21
.=
(F [;] d,(id D)) . (F . (f . c),(f' . c))
by FUNCOP_1:48
.=
F . d,
((id D) . (F . (f . c),(f' . c)))
by FUNCOP_1:66
.=
F . d,
(F . (f . c),(f' . c))
by FUNCT_1:35
.=
F . (F . d,(f . c)),
(f' . c)
by A1, BINOP_1:def 3
.=
F . ((F [;] d,f) . c),
(f' . c)
by FUNCOP_1:66
.=
F . (((F [;] d,(id D)) * f) . c),
(f' . c)
by FUNCOP_1:69
.=
(F .: ((F [;] d,(id D)) * f),f') . c
by FUNCOP_1:48
;
:: thesis: verum end;
hence
(F [;] d,(id D)) * (F .: f,f') = F .: ((F [;] d,(id D)) * f),f'
by FUNCT_2:113; :: thesis: verum