let p, p1, p2, p3 be Point of (TOP-REAL 2); :: thesis: ( p in LSeg p1,p2 & not p3 in LSeg p1,p2 & angle p1,p3,p2 > PI & p <> p2 implies angle p,p3,p2 >= angle p1,p3,p2 )
assume A1:
p in LSeg p1,p2
; :: thesis: ( p3 in LSeg p1,p2 or not angle p1,p3,p2 > PI or not p <> p2 or angle p,p3,p2 >= angle p1,p3,p2 )
assume A2:
not p3 in LSeg p1,p2
; :: thesis: ( not angle p1,p3,p2 > PI or not p <> p2 or angle p,p3,p2 >= angle p1,p3,p2 )
assume A3:
angle p1,p3,p2 > PI
; :: thesis: ( not p <> p2 or angle p,p3,p2 >= angle p1,p3,p2 )
assume A4:
p <> p2
; :: thesis: angle p,p3,p2 >= angle p1,p3,p2
assume A5:
angle p,p3,p2 < angle p1,p3,p2
; :: thesis: contradiction
per cases
( p = p1 or p1 = p2 or ( p1 <> p2 & p <> p1 ) )
;
suppose A7:
(
p1 <> p2 &
p <> p1 )
;
:: thesis: contradictionA8:
(
p3 <> p1 &
p3 <> p2 )
by A2, RLTOPSP1:69;
then A9:
(
euc2cpx p3 <> euc2cpx p2 &
euc2cpx p3 <> euc2cpx p1 &
euc2cpx p2 <> euc2cpx p1 )
by A7, EUCLID_3:6;
A10:
(
euc2cpx p <> euc2cpx p3 &
euc2cpx p <> euc2cpx p2 &
euc2cpx p <> euc2cpx p1 )
by A1, A2, A4, A7, EUCLID_3:6;
A11:
angle p3,
p2,
p1 = angle p3,
p2,
p
by A1, A4, Th10;
(angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = (angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p,p3)
proof
per cases
( ( ((angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p1)) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = PI & ((angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p)) + (angle p2,p,p3) = PI ) or ( ((angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p1)) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = 5 * PI & ((angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p)) + (angle p2,p,p3) = 5 * PI ) or ( ((angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p1)) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = PI & ((angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p)) + (angle p2,p,p3) = 5 * PI ) or ( ((angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p1)) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = 5 * PI & ((angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p)) + (angle p2,p,p3) = PI ) )
by A9, A10, COMPLEX2:102;
suppose
(
((angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p1)) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = PI &
((angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p)) + (angle p2,p,p3) = PI )
;
:: thesis: (angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = (angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p,p3)end; suppose
(
((angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p1)) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = 5
* PI &
((angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p)) + (angle p2,p,p3) = 5
* PI )
;
:: thesis: (angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = (angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p,p3)end; suppose A12:
(
((angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p1)) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = PI &
((angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p)) + (angle p2,p,p3) = 5
* PI )
;
:: thesis: (angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = (angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p,p3)A13:
(
angle p1,
p3,
p2 >= 0 &
angle p2,
p1,
p3 >= 0 &
angle p,
p3,
p2 < 2
* PI &
angle p2,
p,
p3 < 2
* PI )
by COMPLEX2:84;
then
(
- (angle p2,p,p3) > - (2 * PI ) &
- (angle p,p3,p2) > - (2 * PI ) )
by XREAL_1:26;
then A14:
(- (angle p,p3,p2)) + (- (angle p2,p,p3)) > (- (2 * PI )) + (- (2 * PI ))
by XREAL_1:10;
(angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p1,p3) >= 0 + 0
by A13;
then
((angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p1,p3)) + ((- (angle p,p3,p2)) - (angle p2,p,p3)) > (0 + 0 ) + ((- (2 * PI )) - (2 * PI ))
by A14, XREAL_1:10;
hence
(angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = (angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p,p3)
by A11, A12;
:: thesis: verum end; suppose A15:
(
((angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p1)) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = 5
* PI &
((angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p3,p2,p)) + (angle p2,p,p3) = PI )
;
:: thesis: (angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = (angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p,p3)A16:
(
angle p2,
p1,
p3 < 2
* PI &
angle p1,
p3,
p2 < 2
* PI &
angle p,
p3,
p2 >= 0 &
angle p2,
p,
p3 >= 0 )
by COMPLEX2:84;
then A17:
(angle p2,p1,p3) + (angle p1,p3,p2) < (2 * PI ) + (2 * PI )
by XREAL_1:10;
(
- (angle p2,p,p3) <= - 0 &
- (angle p,p3,p2) <= - 0 )
by A16;
then
(- (angle p,p3,p2)) + (- (angle p2,p,p3)) <= 0 + 0
;
then
((angle p2,p1,p3) + (angle p1,p3,p2)) + ((- (angle p,p3,p2)) - (angle p2,p,p3)) < ((2 * PI ) + (2 * PI )) + (0 + 0 )
by A17, XREAL_1:10;
hence
(angle p1,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p1,p3) = (angle p,p3,p2) + (angle p2,p,p3)
by A11, A15;
:: thesis: verum end; end;
end; then
angle p2,
p1,
p3 < angle p2,
p,
p3
by A5, XREAL_1:10;
then A18:
angle p,
p1,
p3 < angle p2,
p,
p3
by A1, Th9;
per cases
( ( (angle p2,p,p3) + (angle p3,p,p1) = PI & ((angle p3,p,p1) + (angle p,p1,p3)) + (angle p1,p3,p) = PI ) or ( (angle p2,p,p3) + (angle p3,p,p1) = 3 * PI & ((angle p3,p,p1) + (angle p,p1,p3)) + (angle p1,p3,p) = PI ) or ( (angle p2,p,p3) + (angle p3,p,p1) = PI & ((angle p3,p,p1) + (angle p,p1,p3)) + (angle p1,p3,p) = 5 * PI ) or ( (angle p2,p,p3) + (angle p3,p,p1) = 3 * PI & ((angle p3,p,p1) + (angle p,p1,p3)) + (angle p1,p3,p) = 5 * PI ) )
by A1, A9, A10, Th13, COMPLEX2:102;
suppose A19:
(
(angle p2,p,p3) + (angle p3,p,p1) = PI &
((angle p3,p,p1) + (angle p,p1,p3)) + (angle p1,p3,p) = PI )
;
:: thesis: contradiction
p1,
p3,
p2 are_mutually_different
by A7, A8, ZFMISC_1:def 5;
then
angle p2,
p1,
p3 > PI
by A3, Th24;
then A20:
angle p,
p1,
p3 > PI
by A1, A7, Th9;
p,
p1,
p3 are_mutually_different
by A1, A2, A7, A8, ZFMISC_1:def 5;
then
(
angle p1,
p3,
p > PI &
angle p3,
p,
p1 > PI )
by A20, Th24;
then
(angle p3,p,p1) + (angle p1,p3,p) > PI + PI
by XREAL_1:10;
then A21:
((angle p3,p,p1) + (angle p1,p3,p)) + (angle p,p1,p3) > (2 * PI ) + PI
by A20, XREAL_1:10;
1
* PI < 3
* PI
by XREAL_1:70;
hence
contradiction
by A19, A21;
:: thesis: verum end; suppose
(
(angle p2,p,p3) + (angle p3,p,p1) = 3
* PI &
((angle p3,p,p1) + (angle p,p1,p3)) + (angle p1,p3,p) = PI )
;
:: thesis: contradictionthen A22:
angle p2,
p,
p3 = ((angle p,p1,p3) + (angle p1,p3,p)) + (2 * PI )
;
(
angle p,
p1,
p3 >= 0 &
angle p1,
p3,
p >= 0 )
by COMPLEX2:84;
then
(angle p,p1,p3) + (angle p1,p3,p) >= 0 + 0
;
then
angle p2,
p,
p3 >= 0 + (2 * PI )
by A22, XREAL_1:8;
hence
contradiction
by COMPLEX2:84;
:: thesis: verum end; suppose A23:
(
(angle p2,p,p3) + (angle p3,p,p1) = PI &
((angle p3,p,p1) + (angle p,p1,p3)) + (angle p1,p3,p) = 5
* PI )
;
:: thesis: contradiction
(
angle p,
p1,
p3 < 2
* PI &
angle p1,
p3,
p < 2
* PI )
by COMPLEX2:84;
then
(angle p,p1,p3) + (angle p1,p3,p) < (2 * PI ) + (2 * PI )
by XREAL_1:10;
then
(angle p2,p,p3) + (4 * PI ) < 0 + (4 * PI )
by A23;
then
angle p2,
p,
p3 < 0
by XREAL_1:8;
hence
contradiction
by COMPLEX2:84;
:: thesis: verum end; suppose
(
(angle p2,p,p3) + (angle p3,p,p1) = 3
* PI &
((angle p3,p,p1) + (angle p,p1,p3)) + (angle p1,p3,p) = 5
* PI )
;
:: thesis: contradictionthen
(angle p2,p,p3) + (2 * PI ) = (angle p,p1,p3) + (angle p1,p3,p)
;
then
(angle p2,p,p3) + (2 * PI ) < (angle p2,p,p3) + (angle p1,p3,p)
by A18, XREAL_1:8;
then
2
* PI < angle p1,
p3,
p
by XREAL_1:8;
hence
contradiction
by COMPLEX2:84;
:: thesis: verum end; end; end; end;