let Y be non empty set ; :: thesis: for G being Subset of (PARTITIONS Y)
for a, b being Element of Funcs Y,BOOLEAN
for PA being a_partition of Y holds Ex a,PA,G '<' 'not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))
let G be Subset of (PARTITIONS Y); :: thesis: for a, b being Element of Funcs Y,BOOLEAN
for PA being a_partition of Y holds Ex a,PA,G '<' 'not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))
let a, b be Element of Funcs Y,BOOLEAN ; :: thesis: for PA being a_partition of Y holds Ex a,PA,G '<' 'not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))
let PA be a_partition of Y; :: thesis: Ex a,PA,G '<' 'not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))
let z be Element of Y; :: according to BVFUNC_1:def 15 :: thesis: ( not (Ex a,PA,G) . z = TRUE or ('not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))) . z = TRUE )
assume A1:
(Ex a,PA,G) . z = TRUE
; :: thesis: ('not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))) . z = TRUE
then consider x1 being Element of Y such that
A2:
( x1 in EqClass z,(CompF PA,G) & a . x1 = TRUE )
;
A3: (a '&' b) . x1 =
TRUE '&' (b . x1)
by A2, MARGREL1:def 21
.=
b . x1
by MARGREL1:50
;
A4: (a '&' ('not' b)) . x1 =
TRUE '&' (('not' b) . x1)
by A2, MARGREL1:def 21
.=
('not' b) . x1
by MARGREL1:50
;
A5:
('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)) . z = 'not' ((Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G) . z)
by MARGREL1:def 20;
A6: ('not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))) . z =
'not' ((('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G))) . z)
by MARGREL1:def 20
.=
'not' ((('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) . z) '&' (('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)) . z))
by MARGREL1:def 21
.=
'not' (('not' ((Ex (a '&' b),PA,G) . z)) '&' ('not' ((Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G) . z)))
by A5, MARGREL1:def 20
;
per cases
( b . x1 = TRUE or b . x1 = FALSE )
by XBOOLEAN:def 3;
suppose
b . x1 = TRUE
;
:: thesis: ('not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))) . z = TRUE then
(B_SUP (a '&' b),(CompF PA,G)) . z = TRUE
by A2, A3, BVFUNC_1:def 20;
hence ('not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))) . z =
'not' (('not' TRUE ) '&' ('not' ((Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G) . z)))
by A6, BVFUNC_2:def 10
.=
'not' (FALSE '&' ('not' ((Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G) . z)))
by MARGREL1:41
.=
'not' FALSE
by MARGREL1:45
.=
TRUE
by MARGREL1:41
;
:: thesis: verum end; suppose
b . x1 = FALSE
;
:: thesis: ('not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))) . z = TRUE then
(a '&' ('not' b)) . x1 = 'not' FALSE
by A4, MARGREL1:def 20;
then
(a '&' ('not' b)) . x1 = TRUE
by MARGREL1:41;
then
(B_SUP (a '&' ('not' b)),(CompF PA,G)) . z = TRUE
by A2, BVFUNC_1:def 20;
hence ('not' (('not' (Ex (a '&' b),PA,G)) '&' ('not' (Ex (a '&' ('not' b)),PA,G)))) . z =
'not' (('not' ((Ex (a '&' b),PA,G) . z)) '&' ('not' TRUE ))
by A6, BVFUNC_2:def 10
.=
'not' (('not' ((Ex (a '&' b),PA,G) . z)) '&' FALSE )
by MARGREL1:41
.=
'not' FALSE
by MARGREL1:45
.=
TRUE
by MARGREL1:41
;
:: thesis: verum end; end;