let X be RealUnitarySpace; :: thesis: ( the addF of X is commutative & the addF of X is associative & the addF of X is having_a_unity & X is Hilbert implies for S being OrthonormalFamily of X
for H being Functional of X st S c= dom H & ( for x being Point of X st x in S holds
H . x = x .|. x ) holds
( S is summable_set iff S is_summable_set_by H ) )
assume A1:
( the addF of X is commutative & the addF of X is associative & the addF of X is having_a_unity & X is Hilbert )
; :: thesis: for S being OrthonormalFamily of X
for H being Functional of X st S c= dom H & ( for x being Point of X st x in S holds
H . x = x .|. x ) holds
( S is summable_set iff S is_summable_set_by H )
let S be OrthonormalFamily of X; :: thesis: for H being Functional of X st S c= dom H & ( for x being Point of X st x in S holds
H . x = x .|. x ) holds
( S is summable_set iff S is_summable_set_by H )
let H be Functional of X; :: thesis: ( S c= dom H & ( for x being Point of X st x in S holds
H . x = x .|. x ) implies ( S is summable_set iff S is_summable_set_by H ) )
assume A2:
( S c= dom H & ( for x being Point of X st x in S holds
H . x = x .|. x ) )
; :: thesis: ( S is summable_set iff S is_summable_set_by H )
A3:
now assume A4:
S is
summable_set
;
:: thesis: S is_summable_set_by Hnow let e be
Real;
:: thesis: ( 0 < e implies ex Y0 being finite Subset of X st
( not Y0 is empty & Y0 c= S & ( for Y1 being finite Subset of X st not Y1 is empty & Y1 c= S & Y0 misses Y1 holds
abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ) < e ) ) )assume A5:
0 < e
;
:: thesis: ex Y0 being finite Subset of X st
( not Y0 is empty & Y0 c= S & ( for Y1 being finite Subset of X st not Y1 is empty & Y1 c= S & Y0 misses Y1 holds
abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ) < e ) )set e' =
sqrt e;
0 < sqrt e
by A5, SQUARE_1:93;
then consider e1 being
Real such that A6:
(
0 < e1 &
e1 < sqrt e )
by CHAIN_1:1;
e1 ^2 < (sqrt e) ^2
by A6, SQUARE_1:78;
then A7:
(
e1 > 0 &
e1 * e1 < e )
by A5, A6, SQUARE_1:def 4;
consider Y0 being
finite Subset of
X such that A8:
( not
Y0 is
empty &
Y0 c= S & ( for
Y1 being
finite Subset of
X st not
Y1 is
empty &
Y1 c= S &
Y0 misses Y1 holds
||.(setsum Y1).|| < e1 ) )
by A1, A4, A6, BHSP_6:10;
take Y0 =
Y0;
:: thesis: ( not Y0 is empty & Y0 c= S & ( for Y1 being finite Subset of X st not Y1 is empty & Y1 c= S & Y0 misses Y1 holds
abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ) < e ) )thus
( not
Y0 is
empty &
Y0 c= S )
by A8;
:: thesis: for Y1 being finite Subset of X st not Y1 is empty & Y1 c= S & Y0 misses Y1 holds
abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ) < elet Y1 be
finite Subset of
X;
:: thesis: ( not Y1 is empty & Y1 c= S & Y0 misses Y1 implies abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ) < e )assume A9:
( not
Y1 is
empty &
Y1 c= S &
Y0 misses Y1 )
;
:: thesis: abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ) < e
0 <= ||.(setsum Y1).||
by BHSP_1:34;
then
||.(setsum Y1).|| ^2 < e1 ^2
by A8, A9, SQUARE_1:78;
then A10:
||.(setsum Y1).|| ^2 < e
by A7, XXREAL_0:2;
Y1 is
finite OrthonormalFamily of
X
by A9, Th5;
then A11:
Y1 is
finite OrthogonalFamily of
X
by BHSP_5:def 9;
for
x being
Point of
X st
x in Y1 holds
H . x = x .|. x
by A2, A9;
then A13:
(setsum Y1) .|. (setsum Y1) = setopfunc Y1,the
carrier of
X,
REAL ,
H,
addreal
by A1, A9, A11, Th3, A2, XBOOLE_1:1;
A14:
||.(setsum Y1).|| = sqrt ((setsum Y1) .|. (setsum Y1))
by BHSP_1:def 4;
0 <= (setsum Y1) .|. (setsum Y1)
by BHSP_1:def 2;
then A15:
||.(setsum Y1).|| ^2 = setopfunc Y1,the
carrier of
X,
REAL ,
H,
addreal
by A13, A14, SQUARE_1:def 4;
0 <= setopfunc Y1,the
carrier of
X,
REAL ,
H,
addreal
by A13, BHSP_1:def 2;
hence
abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ) < e
by A10, A15, ABSVALUE:def 1;
:: thesis: verum end; hence
S is_summable_set_by H
by Th1;
:: thesis: verum end;
now assume A16:
S is_summable_set_by H
;
:: thesis: S is summable_set now let e be
Real;
:: thesis: ( 0 < e implies ex Y0 being finite Subset of X st
( not Y0 is empty & Y0 c= S & ( for Y1 being finite Subset of X st not Y1 is empty & Y1 c= S & Y0 misses Y1 holds
||.(setsum Y1).|| < e ) ) )assume A17:
0 < e
;
:: thesis: ex Y0 being finite Subset of X st
( not Y0 is empty & Y0 c= S & ( for Y1 being finite Subset of X st not Y1 is empty & Y1 c= S & Y0 misses Y1 holds
||.(setsum Y1).|| < e ) )set e1 =
e * e;
(
0 < e * e &
e * e = e * e )
by A17, XREAL_1:131;
then consider Y0 being
finite Subset of
X such that A18:
( not
Y0 is
empty &
Y0 c= S & ( for
Y1 being
finite Subset of
X st not
Y1 is
empty &
Y1 c= S &
Y0 misses Y1 holds
abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ) < e * e ) )
by A16, Th1;
now let Y1 be
finite Subset of
X;
:: thesis: ( not Y1 is empty & Y1 c= S & Y0 misses Y1 implies ||.(setsum Y1).|| < e )assume A19:
( not
Y1 is
empty &
Y1 c= S &
Y0 misses Y1 )
;
:: thesis: ||.(setsum Y1).|| < eset F =
setopfunc Y1,the
carrier of
X,
REAL ,
H,
addreal ;
A20:
abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ) < e * e
by A18, A19;
setopfunc Y1,the
carrier of
X,
REAL ,
H,
addreal <= abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal )
by ABSVALUE:11;
then
(setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ) - (e * e) < (abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal )) - (abs (setopfunc Y1,the carrier of X,REAL ,H,addreal ))
by A20, XREAL_1:17;
then A21:
setopfunc Y1,the
carrier of
X,
REAL ,
H,
addreal < e * e
by XREAL_1:50;
Y1 is
finite OrthonormalFamily of
X
by A19, Th5;
then A22:
Y1 is
finite OrthogonalFamily of
X
by BHSP_5:def 9;
for
x being
Point of
X st
x in Y1 holds
H . x = x .|. x
by A2, A19;
then A24:
(setsum Y1) .|. (setsum Y1) = setopfunc Y1,the
carrier of
X,
REAL ,
H,
addreal
by A1, A19, A22, Th3, A2, XBOOLE_1:1;
A25:
0 <= (setsum Y1) .|. (setsum Y1)
by BHSP_1:def 2;
||.(setsum Y1).|| = sqrt ((setsum Y1) .|. (setsum Y1))
by BHSP_1:def 4;
then
||.(setsum Y1).|| ^2 < e * e
by A21, A24, A25, SQUARE_1:def 4;
then
sqrt (||.(setsum Y1).|| ^2 ) < sqrt (e ^2 )
by SQUARE_1:95, XREAL_1:65;
then
sqrt (||.(setsum Y1).|| ^2 ) < e
by A17, SQUARE_1:89;
hence
||.(setsum Y1).|| < e
by BHSP_1:34, SQUARE_1:89;
:: thesis: verum end; hence
ex
Y0 being
finite Subset of
X st
( not
Y0 is
empty &
Y0 c= S & ( for
Y1 being
finite Subset of
X st not
Y1 is
empty &
Y1 c= S &
Y0 misses Y1 holds
||.(setsum Y1).|| < e ) )
by A18;
:: thesis: verum end; hence
S is
summable_set
by A1, BHSP_6:10;
:: thesis: verum end;
hence
( S is summable_set iff S is_summable_set_by H )
by A3; :: thesis: verum