let V be non trivial RealLinearSpace; :: thesis: for p1, r2, q, r1, q1, p, r being Element of (ProjectiveSpace V) st p1,r2,q is_collinear & r1,q1,q is_collinear & p1,r1,p is_collinear & r2,q1,p is_collinear & p1,q1,r is_collinear & r2,r1,r is_collinear & p,q,r is_collinear & not p1,r2,q1 is_collinear & not p1,r2,r1 is_collinear & not p1,r1,q1 is_collinear holds
r2,r1,q1 is_collinear
let p1, r2, q, r1, q1, p, r be Element of (ProjectiveSpace V); :: thesis: ( p1,r2,q is_collinear & r1,q1,q is_collinear & p1,r1,p is_collinear & r2,q1,p is_collinear & p1,q1,r is_collinear & r2,r1,r is_collinear & p,q,r is_collinear & not p1,r2,q1 is_collinear & not p1,r2,r1 is_collinear & not p1,r1,q1 is_collinear implies r2,r1,q1 is_collinear )
assume A1:
( p1,r2,q is_collinear & r1,q1,q is_collinear & p1,r1,p is_collinear & r2,q1,p is_collinear & p1,q1,r is_collinear & r2,r1,r is_collinear & p,q,r is_collinear )
; :: thesis: ( p1,r2,q1 is_collinear or p1,r2,r1 is_collinear or p1,r1,q1 is_collinear or r2,r1,q1 is_collinear )
then consider u, v, z being Element of V such that
A2:
( p1 = Dir u & r2 = Dir v & q = Dir z & not u is zero & not v is zero & not z is zero & u,v,z are_LinDep )
by Th24;
consider w, y, z1 being Element of V such that
A3:
( r1 = Dir w & q1 = Dir y & q = Dir z1 & not w is zero & not y is zero & not z1 is zero & w,y,z1 are_LinDep )
by A1, Th24;
consider u1, w1, x being Element of V such that
A4:
( p1 = Dir u1 & r1 = Dir w1 & p = Dir x & not u1 is zero & not w1 is zero & not x is zero & u1,w1,x are_LinDep )
by A1, Th24;
consider v1, y1, x1 being Element of V such that
A5:
( r2 = Dir v1 & q1 = Dir y1 & p = Dir x1 & not v1 is zero & not y1 is zero & not x1 is zero & v1,y1,x1 are_LinDep )
by A1, Th24;
consider u2, y2, t being Element of V such that
A6:
( p1 = Dir u2 & q1 = Dir y2 & r = Dir t & not u2 is zero & not y2 is zero & not t is zero & u2,y2,t are_LinDep )
by A1, Th24;
consider v2, w2, t1 being Element of V such that
A7:
( r2 = Dir v2 & r1 = Dir w2 & r = Dir t1 & not v2 is zero & not w2 is zero & not t1 is zero & v2,w2,t1 are_LinDep )
by A1, Th24;
consider x2, z2, t2 being Element of V such that
A8:
( p = Dir x2 & q = Dir z2 & r = Dir t2 & not x2 is zero & not z2 is zero & not t2 is zero & x2,z2,t2 are_LinDep )
by A1, Th24;
( u,v,z are_LinDep & w,y,z are_LinDep & u,w,x are_LinDep & v,y,x are_LinDep & u,y,t are_LinDep & v,w,t are_LinDep & x,z,t are_LinDep )
proof
A9:
(
are_Prop z1,
z &
are_Prop w1,
w &
are_Prop u1,
u )
by A2, A3, A4, ANPROJ_1:35;
A10:
(
are_Prop y1,
y &
are_Prop x1,
x )
by A3, A4, A5, ANPROJ_1:35;
A11:
(
are_Prop u2,
u &
are_Prop y2,
y )
by A2, A3, A6, ANPROJ_1:35;
A12:
(
are_Prop v2,
v &
are_Prop w2,
w )
by A2, A3, A7, ANPROJ_1:35;
A13:
(
are_Prop t1,
t &
are_Prop x2,
x )
by A4, A6, A7, A8, ANPROJ_1:35;
A14:
(
are_Prop z2,
z &
are_Prop t2,
t )
by A2, A6, A8, ANPROJ_1:35;
A15:
are_Prop v1,
v
by A2, A5, ANPROJ_1:35;
thus
u,
v,
z are_LinDep
by A2;
:: thesis: ( w,y,z are_LinDep & u,w,x are_LinDep & v,y,x are_LinDep & u,y,t are_LinDep & v,w,t are_LinDep & x,z,t are_LinDep )
thus
w,
y,
z are_LinDep
by A3, A9, ANPROJ_1:9;
:: thesis: ( u,w,x are_LinDep & v,y,x are_LinDep & u,y,t are_LinDep & v,w,t are_LinDep & x,z,t are_LinDep )
thus
u,
w,
x are_LinDep
by A4, A9, ANPROJ_1:9;
:: thesis: ( v,y,x are_LinDep & u,y,t are_LinDep & v,w,t are_LinDep & x,z,t are_LinDep )
thus
v,
y,
x are_LinDep
by A5, A10, A15, ANPROJ_1:9;
:: thesis: ( u,y,t are_LinDep & v,w,t are_LinDep & x,z,t are_LinDep )
thus
u,
y,
t are_LinDep
by A6, A11, ANPROJ_1:9;
:: thesis: ( v,w,t are_LinDep & x,z,t are_LinDep )
thus
v,
w,
t are_LinDep
by A7, A12, A13, ANPROJ_1:9;
:: thesis: x,z,t are_LinDep
thus
x,
z,
t are_LinDep
by A8, A13, A14, ANPROJ_1:9;
:: thesis: verum
end;
then
( u,v,y are_LinDep or u,v,w are_LinDep or u,w,y are_LinDep or v,w,y are_LinDep )
by A2, A4, A6, ANPROJ_1:23;
hence
( p1,r2,q1 is_collinear or p1,r2,r1 is_collinear or p1,r1,q1 is_collinear or r2,r1,q1 is_collinear )
by A2, A3, Th24; :: thesis: verum