let P be Simple_closed_curve; :: thesis: for a, b, c, d being Point of () st a <> b & b <> c & c <> d & a,b,c,d are_in_this_order_on P & a,d,c,b are_in_this_order_on P holds
b = d

let a, b, c, d be Point of (); :: thesis: ( a <> b & b <> c & c <> d & a,b,c,d are_in_this_order_on P & a,d,c,b are_in_this_order_on P implies b = d )
assume that
A1: a <> b and
A2: b <> c and
A3: c <> d and
A4: a,b,c,d are_in_this_order_on P and
A5: a,d,c,b are_in_this_order_on P ; :: thesis: b = d
per cases ( ( LE a,b,P & LE b,c,P & LE c,d,P ) or ( LE b,c,P & LE c,d,P & LE d,a,P ) or ( LE c,d,P & LE d,a,P & LE a,b,P ) or ( LE d,a,P & LE a,b,P & LE b,c,P ) ) by A4;
suppose A6: ( LE a,b,P & LE b,c,P & LE c,d,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
thus b = d :: thesis: verum
proof
per cases ( ( LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P ) or ( LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P ) or ( LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P ) or ( LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P ) ) by A5;
suppose ( LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
end;
end;
end;
suppose A7: ( LE b,c,P & LE c,d,P & LE d,a,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
thus b = d :: thesis: verum
proof
per cases ( ( LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P ) or ( LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P ) or ( LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P ) or ( LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P ) ) by A5;
suppose ( LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
end;
end;
end;
suppose A8: ( LE c,d,P & LE d,a,P & LE a,b,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
thus b = d :: thesis: verum
proof
per cases ( ( LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P ) or ( LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P ) or ( LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P ) or ( LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P ) ) by A5;
suppose ( LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
end;
end;
end;
suppose A9: ( LE d,a,P & LE a,b,P & LE b,c,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
thus b = d :: thesis: verum
proof
per cases ( ( LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P ) or ( LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P ) or ( LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P ) or ( LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P ) ) by A5;
suppose ( LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE d,c,P & LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE c,b,P & LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
suppose ( LE b,a,P & LE a,d,P & LE d,c,P ) ; :: thesis: b = d
hence b = d by ; :: thesis: verum
end;
end;
end;
end;
end;